1.1.9.x Grasping Vines Feedback

I didnt quite get my comments in on the 119x discussion endgame thread, so Ill do a standalone post.
In regards to Grasping vines, Ive tested these builds recently.

Acid retal hybrid archon : Archon, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator - The damage is good, but the build is more or less useless. The super low OA/DA make it impossible to stay alive even with kiting + good kill speed. If the build had more movespeed + more DA/OA I think it would be a solid mid tier performer. Can pull a 430 run with masterful piloting and good mutators. 20% completion rate

Lightning retal hybrid archon : Archon, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator - All around pretty good average build… can clear fairly consistently around 5 mins. The new flat RR on the ring set and elemental rr on guardians made the build actually work. (And about 30seconds faster than my old warder version Warder, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator) A little thin on sustain due to middling speeds.

Wildblood Acid Archon - Archon, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator The creme de le 'Meme… it was a ~5:30 -5:45 build prior to wildblood nerfs Not sure where it is now. probably in that ballpark still

Wildblood bleeding trickster : Trickster, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator pretty solid build, mad_lee’s version. can pull a 4:30 or a bit under run… Still could use a bit more oomph

Demonslayer + offhand trickster : Trickster, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator - Really no reason to play this version. Totally out classed by blade spirit shield version by grey_maybe. Damage is okay, but total paperdoll. Gets shreded easy. Not really sure where to use this offhand outside of leveling to transition to Wildblood… If thats the intention, then thats fine as long as there are other working builds for it

Gutripper Bleeding phys/pierce archon - Archon, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator - Pretty thin on damage and sustain even with 1.1k regen. Gameplay requires kiting 5:15-5:30 on good mutators… bad ones like shattered and you will be lucky to finish a run. The extra 10% weapon damage from the medal for savagery helped a bit

Gutripper + goredrinker archon - Archon, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator - Mega low cast speed. I would like to fit kraken into the devotions, but that would mean giving up a t3 which is needed for sustain. Even with over 50% adtch in game the leech feels weak. Vines arent doing much due to really only being there more bleeding phys damage is wasted… Bleed stacks are pretty good though. Not competitive on speeds

Standard Wildblood vit conjurer + rit - Been awhile since ive played them, but im assuming they are still solid ~5 or under builds with little risk of death… Plan on testing this version with reaping arc spam Ritualist, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator looks like a very strong contender

Bonus Warder build : Warder, Level 100 (GD 1.1.9.3) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator

With all of that said, these are some of the changes I personally would like to see.

  • Weapon damage added to the baseline skill. Scaling would be small starting at say 4% to 12% at level 12 to maybe 18% at level 22. This would allow for a piercing/bleed version to be built with gutripper + goredrinker with different devotion pathing. It also would fix to some degree the sustain issue seen on all non-wildblood vines builds by allowing some portion of adcth to be passed to vines. Obviously the WD mods on wildblood would need to be scaled back a bit
  • Sprinkle more skill points on relevant gear slots. Search - Grim Dawn Item Database thats the search for vines on grimtools. I havent double checked, but Im positive grasping vines/ entangling vines are some of the least supported skills on gear. Only 28 items excluding lower level versions for all slots for both skill nodes combined
  • Add % vitality or % pierce damage to the carnage ring set to make them competitive with orisa rings and cast speed (tbh I would rather see vit as Vit/bleed is a more fun concept to me)
  • Add %pierce damage to bloodsurge as a gearing choice for pierce vine builds and cast speed since it is a vines item
  • Add RtA, Adcth, wd, or flat bleed to Misery… some combo of these would be nice… perhaps adcth and bleed for a meme acid/bleeding hybrid?
  • Give Irkix Scale vines support in addition to or instead of overguard (think lightning RtA and a cool FX please and thank you! :smiley: )
    From the season 3 community mod

  • Add some DA/OA bonuses to gear slots that do support vine skill points
15 Likes

And more mods to Vines!

1 Like

Hands away from Overguard! :angry:

I did say in addition to OR instead of. I just wasn’t particularly aware of lightning retal soldiers using the medal. Although I suppose it would fit for the purple dawn set. I wouldnt advocate for nerfing something niche

1 Like

Not only Lightning Retal Soldiers, but Retal Soldiers overall (I know about Voracious medal and Markovian Stratagem, but they do not have flexible affixes, and healing from Overguard is great). I do not mind adding modifiers to Grasping Vines, but not at the cost of other bonuses.

Also it probably would be worth it to move some portion of the duration mods to the base skill, and reduce it on items

I tried this particular build:

and well … it has a bunch of problems.

  • single-RR acid is very annoying and unpleasant to play in general;
  • despite fat mods to Vines, damage is very meh (like 6+ mins for a complete run), sustain is bad too;
  • low CS as neither of the supporting gear has it;
  • despite some racial, Alex is a wasted run.

I suggest the following:

  • add like 15% total damage modifier to shield/conduit aswell as like 20% RR to Vines. same for some LL - on shield, sword etc. Drastic changes but I think they’re quite fair for such a slow setup.
  • add cast speed to sword/anywhere on supporting gear.
  • add bonus points to vines/mods for acid gear.

I’d also really love to see more Vines (like lightning ones) support in-game as now it’s hard to get all the ranks.

2 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.