Deadly Momentum is exploited by DAR skills

Global buff tied to a skill can always end up being exploited by other skills, if the payout is worth the investment.

Deadly Momentum, it seems, was buffed enough to go over this threshold: stats on it are overwhelming, and the white gear piece crafts can help hardcap it on almost any Soldier build.

If this was an intended consequence, I personally don’t like this: every WD based Soldier build is now prompted to pay a hefty QoL and… harmony? price to reach its maximum potential. But if this was a little unexpected, I suggest to curb the exploit in some way. The easiest solution is probably to lower Deadly Momentum duration to 3.5 seconds. This way any Cadence build, even with 100% attack speed will have the buff up as long as it’s attacking, but for the exploiting builds alterating between Cadence and DAR will be much harder.

The awareness of this dynamic is on @mi023. I just quickly tested it on a random build to confirm the universal usage of this exploit. The following build has very high solo dmg reaching sub 20 sec vs Ravager when set up before the fight, but pretty bad AoE, overall nothing gamebreaking. But when paired with Deadly Momentum it increases its Onslaught tooltip by about 60% on average:

11 Likes

Holiday weekend in my country so I can’t write long posts but I need to voice supoort for this since playtest is almost over.

This “exploit” has been around since the beginning of GD and before today, it saw the most use around early AoM when builds weren’t more streamlined and people had to resort to gimmicks like this (and also savagery stacking stats for non savagery builds) to get needed stats.

Thing is DM mods got so good now (rightfully so, it’s the result of a long discussion on how to make cadence better) that it’s now basically a better lethal assault. I’d still never use it because it feels too gimmicky, and imo it’s on the same tier as the weapon swap exploits which I’ll also never do. But if weapon swaps got fixed then this needs a fix too.

Long terms solution is to disable DM when you use a DAR other than cadence but since the playtest is ending maybe a temporary nerf can work as banana suggested

6 Likes

Or why Ravager is irrelevant nowadays - because you just have 100% uptime and boss fights are under 1 buff window usually. Also… why it is an exploit, just read the note fully, it is literally specified “affects all attacks while active”.
Also now please repeat that for something like Calla or Nerf please, bosses which require you to drop uptime. And you quickly notice how one extra button with 3 attacks time to cast and 5 sec buff only is not that huge dps uptime in reality.

how does calla or nerf make you drop uptime when you reposition for 1sec? :thinking: - any thing that lets you regular facetank(ie minor evade move wingflap/meatball) will let you keep buff uptimes
Bero might not let you keep uptime on melee because that naughty thing keeps leaving the ground

First of all, both Nerf and Calla are gimmicky fights that depend on piloting as much as they depend on the build sometimes. Measuring your build with performance in those fights is inadequate. Is Ravager a reliable performance benchmark? Not really, but it’s a good dps benchmark and simulates the amount of pressure your build is going to have in Nemeses/boss fights in SR and Ascendant somewhat well. And in most of those fights you are not gonna be jumping around and doing the song dance you have to do against Nerf.
Second of all, in Calla fights or at least the way we do it Deadly Momentum buff is going to be always up. Here is an example.

On topic: yeah, with Deadly Momentum being this good this seems to be like the way to go for auto-attacking Soldiers. Which makes all of them inherently awkward to use. I think resetting it when attacking with another auto-attack is a good solution. At the same time it can be useful for Blitz builds for example (or even Aegis builds, who knows).

2 Likes

Exploit is not the same thing as bug.

1 Like

Did this one for the memes and this feedback:

Belgo BM 18 seconds Ravager kill (Deadly Momentum spec)

Compare it to the similiar Banana’s Belgo BM spec I based this on that doesn’t have DM but does have a superior (for single target damage) secondary wps (Execution). Same timer however Banana’s kill was from the time of permanent Amplicorum which means nowadays it’s gonna be 3-4 seconds worse probably.

I think this is why @Ceno , @Heapheaus others, myself included, were just hoping for a bit meatier cadence in ultimate ranks and late game item skill modifiers, as opposed to deadly momentum.

That being said, managing this by lowering Deadly Momentum’s duration is a pretty interesting idea! It even opens up the possibility of itemization extending its duration via skill modifiers on weapon slots or sets for the express purpose of using it with another DAR, but limiting which builds can effectively do so.

1 Like

recorded with the same conditions as on your video, without a tdm pot the build is 22 sec vs Ravager now

1 Like

This is a big nerf to many other soldier builds. Blade arc, Blitz, Forcewave all have weapon damage to use that flat damage. Terrible solution.

This is much better, cadence builds should be buffed at the source. And honestly, deadly momentum’s damage should be spread across the skill tree instead. Nerf DM and improve some other passive buffs to compensate.

Suggested it a few times before, didn’t happen. I don’t understand why the class with all its skills being WD based has no flat outside of Deadly Momentum.

It’s not a nerf for cd skills, where Cadence is a filler and a buff provider. It’s a big nerf to spam Forcewave and BA, but you shouldn’t be forced to use two different spam skills in this game. It’s not built for that. The input fidelity is horrible in this engine.

6 Likes

I very specifically mentioned this being overpowered a few weeks ago in discord, I’ve been too busy to fine tune and publish that build. It’s the voidseeker ranged pistols for chaos. Build them with idk something, anything else

I somehow agree with this. Juggling two different DAR skills just to snapshot a massive flat damage buff feels horrible to play and completely ruins the flow of combat. Having to weave Cadence every few seconds on a non-Cadence build is peak piano-clunkiness.

Lowering the duration to 3.5s or straight up disabling DM when attacking with another DAR is the right call.

2 Likes

Thats where I disagree with you. Mechanically yes, he is a good dps dummy. But he has not enough health nowadays for stuff like crit variance or non-perma buffs (like Call of the Grave) to be active whatever real percent uptime they have.

Also I think “ease of piloting” is something worth measuring in builds too as a primary metric. And weaving 1 spam skill into another spam skill is not that trivial and should be rewarded with a good reward, am I wrong?

And here buff does exactly what it declare, it fits into “press extra button 3 times for a short buff” which is usually rewarded.

Thane, Level 100 (GD 1.3.1.0) - Grim Dawn Build Calculator this is specifically what I was trying to fine tune. Someone with more time than I currently has is free to go and bully the red cow dog thing.

You didn’t understand what I said. Exploit means the usage of mechanics that are technically intended by the game code in ways that would be unintended - usually by the devs. And then getting results that are so much better than expected (otherwise you’d just call it a gimmick instead of an exploit).

This exploit/gimmick has existed since the beginning of Grim Dawn but they weren’t popular because it’s a pain in the ass to execute and the returns weren’t great, but now the returns are way better than ever. We’re reporting this because we think the results are unintended, though the final arbiter of that is of course zantai and crate.

3 Likes

i’m gonna take a stab that “other attacks” was never meant as other DARs, let alone to the point of it being superior to have 2 dar’s like that.

cadence doesn’t require 3 button presses, you switch finger, hold it down for a sec and that’s it (also never mind the technical side where cadence doesnt’ actually require 3 button presses because of dual wield/wps and fast charging)

Looking at it from this point of view, if DM is being used to buff another DAR then it certainly hasn’t fixed Cadence.

5 Likes

Yeah, this is the way. Instead of just give some buffs to cadence itself as people here asked, they desided to overbuff momentum instead. Expecting another drama when they nerf it to the ground.

Remember that meme of the swimming pool parents doting all over the Berseker class while Soldier and Inquisitor were found decaying in the bottom of the ocean? Now Soldier has good things that bring people to play it and the first instinct is to call for nerfs…

I get it - Cadence should have its own identity and be something other than “the annoying thing we have to press in order to get the thing that we actually want which is Deadly Momentum.” On the other hand, there should be a sense of positive anticipation and investing a lot in one thing should lead to appropriate rewards.

This is likely the best solution as well, but the fact that a single one-handed pistol has practically the same Deadly Momentum modifier buff as the 4-pc Worldkeeper’s full set bonus was obviously way too much. Finding a sweet spot that keeps the enticement that Deadly Momentum brings while also giving Cadence an identity that’s more than “the thing that procs DM” is the best route of action.