I’ve also tried to use WoP as a main damage skill several times over the years, and never succeeded.
However, I’ve done this with devouring swarm:
The problem with most debuffs is that even though some of them have mods available that increase their damage output, they don,t also have the incredible synergy that DS has with itself and the damage mods that are available. Most items that boost DS’ damage also provide additional RR for the same damage type ![]()
The comparisons to WoP are valid, as the best results I ever had trying to make it great was when I converted it to a damage type it already has RR for.
That also doesn’t take into account the fact that while vitality is (marginally) the most resisted damage type in the game, bleed is the LEAST resisted one.
As for the Vitality RR value on it, it’s not the only skill with a different RR value for a damage type in the game. CoF has basically the same RR for everything… except it has the biggest bleed RR value in the game. Just like Shaman for Vitality, Occultist has barely any bleed support outside of the RR it provides, compared to the multitude of skills it has that deal vitality damage.
There is also the idea that for MOST enemies in the game that are not super bosses, the resistance value they have is not high enough to make 10% extra RR worth that much more than an extra 125% damage in the chosen type if you went with another mastery that has normal RR value but also actually supports the damage type in some way.