I am willing to sacrifice both TDM potion modifiers in return for both versions of Bobr losing the heal ![]()
When I first fought Nerf I thought the fight was supposed to be a marathon ie. you had to wait for him to consume the beavers around the ring so he couldn’t heal anymore.
I was so disappointed when he kept healing lol. If they made it a timed survival like that, I think it’d be a fun end game challenge of your piloting skills rather than a DPS check, which I agree I don’t like in principal.
/rant
I finally managed to fight Nerf for the first time, encountering it without knowing anything about the boss or the fight. After a few deaths, I learned how to fight it pretty well. I was using a tankier build with below-average damage, so I swapped my medal to Brawler’s Distinction to counter its healing. It worked quite well.
I was making progress and was quite sure that, after a couple more attempts, I was going to kill it.
And then, with the boss at 20% of its health, I reached the “enrage” phase.
Fuck this fight to be honest. The healing is fine, can drag the fight out a bit if your dps are low, but making the fight borderline impossible if you don’t kill it fast enough is bad design in my opinion, especially for a game that prides itself on its build variety.
Other superbosses can be tanked, kited, dodged, bled or poisoned to death. They offer a variety of approaches. Nerf, on the other hand, is one of the most curated fights, but in the end the only thing that matters is your damage.
I get that it’s a secret boss with its own quirks, but I’ve never seen such a bad dps check in this game before.
tbh, my gripe with nerf wasn’t even the wave spam, that just felt like me screwing up.
But similar with Bero i feel penalized as melee, having extra downtime from meteors, blood pools, and having to bait borb to move to me (while ofc being in a position that doesn’t subsequently screw me on next meteor or pool).
My AAR warlock did not have the dps to deal with Nerf(didn’t wanna use cheese medal). But felt like much less of a hassle funnily enough.
And i don’t know if it’s a settings issue, but i swear i got bloodpool hit before the pool appeared. I died multiple times to regular waves despite evading, guessing there is dmg to some degree in tail extension ?
But i’ve no clue which part of the wave hits me/can kill me, i just evade and hope i make it the right distance to not end the fight.
All of which is very Bero vibe’esque as melee to me
and has FoA with this “well, you guys said melee was best last game version, so now we’re gonna switch that”. (tho suppose not really fair to paint FoA as a whole with that since it’s only a couple bosses that makes me dislike melee)
I’m not trying to be sarcastic, but how can it be you screwing up? Not fast enough? I get that if you spent half of the fight walking around it’s your fault, but what if your damage output simply isn’t high enough?
I would be fine with it if, again, the fight wasn’t on a timer. If melee is going to be penalized and slower, so be it, but don’t make it actually impossible to finish the fight.
then it’s following in line with a bunch of other game design and bosses. - and at a base level i’m ok with dps check encounters existing.
DPS checks are nothing new, not even for secret supers, Crate even indirectly worked like this by making box spawn be impossible to survive eventually if you were too slow.
DPS check is still a DPS check regardless if it takes the form of direct counter heal(Kuba/Milton/Council etc) or counter death dmg.
*i’m also told it’s technically possible to survive wave spam for a bit, so i suppose there’s an extra element to that if so ![]()
there’s not a single dps check fight that’s impossible to finish, the key is always just to, somehow, have the required dps. It’s technically no different than Crate or Kuba even if mechanically the interaction is a ton of floor dmg to punish your lack of dmg v time instead of boxes exploding/“lag” or eternally dragged out fight from heals.
*i’ve no idea what the timer actually is, so i don’t know if it’s “fair” or what. But as mechanic itself i have no issues with it existing, only if it’s unfair in application. (and i’ve not tried bobr on enough homebrew builds to gauge if the dps requirement is unreasnonable or not to prevent wave spam etc avoid waves post spam)
That’s also why i focused on it becoming less fair just from playing a specific archetype, because it increases the dps requirement from all the extra downtime. But doesn’t make it impossible
*it’s important to stress that not all Supers are meant to be cleared by all build setups, and i’m fine with that baseline design, i’m more concerned with where the line is drawn/what it’s impacting.
Also mostly because bobr kinda feel more archetype/“nonsense” punishing than even Crate did as melee(to me). You can’t cluster and push through debuffs like you can cluster and push through crate 'n box dmg. So you have to move half a screen each time. - and then you’re just changing the dps requirement/impacting that timer more than hit 'n run on Crate did i feels like.
So i’m fine with arbitrary timer being there to make it 99% harder if failing said timer, but it might get additionally skewed because of the regular fight interactions then making the timer more penalized from stuff less in your control (build type).
And it’s a similar annoyance i have with Bero then. “oops you picked melee, well have fun having a sucky time then, should have picked ranged to cheese me” ![]()
*again not entirely dissimilar to Crate, but feels worse on bobr i guess
edit. Speaking of the fight being dps check/hard pass fail encounter because of waves (that bobr heals massively impacts), did @Ceno revisit the fight post heal nerf to decide if heal is “fine” now, or still bs that should get 86d ![]()
Yes.
No.
Yes.
I can’t really disagree with you. Despite my opinion being harsher than yours, I think we both consider the fight to be too punishing for specific builds. I simply find the range of builds affected to be too vast (imo even fewer builds can defeat Nerf than Crate), and I find the “timer” aspect particularly frustrating, more so than the healing, despite both being different sides of the same coin.
I know and I agree, but isn’t the line a bit to high? ![]()
like i said, haven’t remotely tried enough build variety to determine that. I’d leave that up to other experienced loggers for now
(that’s not using peak gdstash and ascend affix cherrypick power
)
Crate n’ boxes already filtered out a fair amount of my chars back then, if Bobr filters a bit more i can live with that. But if it filters most but peak theorycraft meta optimal Altar cheesed rerolls/gdstashed ascension affix combo, that might be a bit out of line from past supers atleast. Homebrew fenris reaver or AAR warlock etc not being up to snuff so far i tolerate (not going to remotely pretend they are that optimal, let alone when can’t even survive “tdm pot meta”
)
*still haven’t tested bobr on half a dozen chars tho, some which i can’t even imagine would come close, as they borderline fail in basic Ascended content, like my new dumb Infernal Knight Dreadnaught or chaos canister DN ![]()
Me neither. In fact, I have never mentioned or requested a straight up nerf. I don’t have the knowledge or the desire to test all the top builds to properly test the boss’s balance.
I only wanted to express my frustration (rant
) with the fight design, because at least for me, you either make a complex fight or a DPS/time check. Otherwise, you end up with a fight that’s a mess to balance.
Agreed, but the build I was using had killed most of the Superbosses and is used to farm in juiced altar Ascendant mode, so it’s not exactly total trash.
Bobr would be fun to play against if his enrage waves didn’t reduce my framerate to single digits.
Like… I don’t get it. He spawns waves at the start. No problem. He spawns waves after enraged. Huge lag. Why?
That’s such a cool idea. Hit enrage = double damage but no more heal.
the way i read GT suggests waves are actually cast by “pets”?, so might be it effectively counts like a crap ton of enemies on screen (ai wise)?, combined with flood of (semi) intense FX decals then ![]()
Fixed. /10char
coincidental “challenge” run completed i guess ![]()
(even Winds of Asterkarn more comfy than melee, for those that read my rants)
Wanted to update my rant opinion after some more testing
First of all, I’m kind of a moron
and really underestimated the power increase of a fully Ascended toon. I managed to beat normal Nerfatal with the same character I used when I wrote my first post.
So, my final take is that the boss is actually quite balanced in terms of stats.
I still find the timer frustrating, but the fight is way more manageable than I initially anticipated. Honestly, I’d rather have either the massive healing or the timer, but not both.
So maybe it’s seen some more stealth nerfs, but the wave spam seemed a lot less bad than I was expecting.
Playing a build well-suited for the fight (forcewave IT battlemage), but way too defensively oriented to make the DPS check on Uber, I was able to get my clear (albeit it took upwards of ten tries) with Uber N’erfatal enraging at 40 million health on the successful attempt.
If your build can tank autoattacks and one wave after enrage, you’ve actually got some pretty decent room to survive and outlast as everything else is manageable to dodge. Notably, I don’t think the waves hurt more after enrage, since the enrage doesn’t double pet damage and the waves are scripted to fire from “Aether Trap”.
The heal is now about four million no more than every 35 seconds, and Nullification removes the absorb buff after (so Ulo proc or Ascendant’s Portent also can), so it’s pretty trivial to go positive against it (~114k DPS)
I’m not a huge fan of DPS checks (as somebody who doesn’t enjoy optimizing DPS that much) but this felt a lot better than I was expecting – the balance of trying to get as much pre-enrage DPS in as I could versus how long I can play well post-enrage was actually quite interesting/engaging to me.
I think the most grating part of the fight was just that N’erf sometimes would put down a blood pool and then stand dead-center in it opting to use waves → beaverstorm → frost shotgun → heal, all without ever moving. The uptime mattering makes the bad luck that affects it feel soooo much worse.
the bloodpool/don’t move is what i dislike about Bobr the most, because that’s what makes it a pita on melee while having 0 interaction on ranged. Similar like how i’ve griped about bero feeling too overly anti melee combined with the zoning and then flying away on top.
Tho funnily enough most egregious “vacationing in blood pool” i experienced was on a pet build ![]()
Yeah, I think the blood pools are what made me decide to go the Enrage Survival route instead of rebuilding to try and make the DPS check. If I really cared about uptime that much (and IT forcewave needs like 2 seconds of uptime every 15 seconds or something, it’s pretty ranged) I would have been planting my face firmly in a keyboard every time I got super unlucky.
I was just surprised to find that enrage survival vs dps check actually felt quite well balanced as options to me – from what I’d heard going into the boss, enrage was pretty much game over in seconds.
Agreed on Beronath as well. I kind of wish that most boss abilities just had some sort of dash-to-player built-in past a certain distance, so that ranged gets a bit more pressure and melee gets more positional control. Part of why I made IT cooldown forcewave my main build to start on Asterkarn with (aside Beronath’s Howl seeming really good for it…) is that I felt like a build that didn’t worry much about uptime would be ideal.



