What does Soldier add to a dual-wielding Nightblade in terms of survivalibility aside some hit points? Nothing. Demolitionist gives Vindictive Flame and Blast Shield. Infinitely more useful for a squishy dual-wielder.
Warden has 4 on procs for a two-weapon builder up from 2 and lots of base physical and lightning damage. Shaman has ranged aoe through Primal Strike and Grasping Vines both of which deal physical damage.
Commando again has Vindictive Damage and Blast Shield. Very tough to kill together with Menhir’s Will. There is no skill Nightblade has and Soldier does not if you are a two-weapon user. You can easily substitute Blitz for SS and Forcewave or Blade Arc for AA if you want aoe.
I am absolutely dead serious. Show me the math you actually did that proves Blademasters are mid-tier at best. None of this arbitrary “I decided that there’s no mechanical synergy between Soldier and Nightblade for REASONS” stuff.
I can give you a huge list of reasons Blademasters are top-tier or close to even with subpar gear.
Blademasters have access to Oleron’s Rage.
Blademasters have access to Cadence and thus Fighting Form/Deadly Momentum.
Blademasters have access to BOTH Soldier’s and Nightblade’s generally favorable-for-melee mastery stat pools.
Blademasters have access to Soldier’s fantastic passives and can easily get 100% WPS coverage.
Blademasters have fantastic gearing options (if you can get said gear).
Blademasters have good-to-outright-fantastic Devotion options.
Blademasters can EASILY support pure phys, phys/bleeding, phys/pierce, pure pierce, pierce/bleed and basically any combination supported by Cunning (which they get plenty of). Phys/IT, pierce and bleed are all fantastic damage types that are rarely resisted in huge amounts. Blademasters can even do Cold reasonably well with proper gearing. Might even be able to do Acid/Poison, though not as well as a Witch Hunter.
Blademasters get access to War Cry/Break Morale as a solid phys resist shred, incoming damage reducer, skill-lockdown ability and devotion proccer.
Blademasters get access to both Blitz/Blindside AND Shadow Strike, on TOP of the movement speed boosts from Pneumatic Burst and Oleron’s Rage. They’re so mobile it isn’t funny.
The purpose of having two masteries is making up for the disadvantages of your first class while making your main fighting strategy stronger.
Nightblade is an awesome class. Soldier is an awesome class. However Awesome + Awesome is not always Awesome. Because the classes are too similar. Their strengths do not add up, however their weaknesses do.
Blademaster has bad ranged game and is terrible against monster that return damage. It has mediocre survivalibility especially if you are dual-wielding.
Its strength comes from Devotion skills which are unpredictable. On proc weapon pool easily goes over 100% making your choice skills less likely to fire off.
Redundant is the word that describes the Blademaster.
Mediocre survivability? Tell that to my Blademaster who can facetank every Nemesis with an offensive setup.
I’m out of here. There’s a difference between having an opinion and saying something outright insane. Blademaster is not a mid tier class, it’s easily a top tier class.
Hold on to your opinion but try building a dual-wielding Saboteur and a two-weapon user Warden. Then make the comparison yourself. Nothing I can say can persuade you other than your very self.
Guys i think he’s in denial because a DW Blademaster can outclass any other class combination in terms of both damage and survivability.
Even i had a hard time digesting when i saw a BM in action for the first time, I was like “Is that even possible?”