Let’s see what need to be added to keep the retal sheet the same before and after cunning/spirit boost removing.
Cold: 1240 fire retal flat, or 90% retal damage + 715 fire retal flat, or 230% retal damage.
Pierce: 1730 fire(or elec) retal flat, or 90% retal damage + 1060 fire(or elec) retal flat, or 145% retal damage+ 700 fire(or elec) retal flat,or 260% retal damage.
Vitality: 1326 fire(or elec) retal flat, or 90% retal damage + 710 fire(or elec) retal flat, or 210% retal damage.
Aether: 1000 fire retal flat, or 90% retal damage + 550 fire retal flat, or 215% retal damage.
Chaos: 1681 fire retal flat, or 90% retal damage + 1152 fire retal flat, or 180% retal damage + 700 fire retal flat, or 340% retal damage.
Then let’s see what these builds have in common. They are mainly devotion Messenger of War, Hyrian and Phoenix. These three devotions are widely used by fire retal builds, so let’s take a look at how fire retal builds perform:
and my Fire Retal Ranged RF Paladin:
Video: GD v1.1.9.6 Fire Retal Ranged RF Paladin CR 5:52_单机游戏热门视频
They are not so good as well, considering that they are none-shield and much less tanky than shield ones, they deserve some more damage love I think.
So I would suggest add altogether 90% retal damage and 700 fire retal flat to these three devotions. The bigger part is the fire retal flat so we don’t have to worry that they would be abused by physical retal because there is no more armor bypass.
Besides, we could give about 90% retal damage to Mythical Sash of the Bloodlord, and 55% retal damage to Mythical Pack of Treacherous Means, to keep the pierce one and the chaos one untouched.