I personally find myself between both your positions.
I agree that the reason why most meme builds don’t get posted is that they are essentially the same as another build, but performs slightly worse… That’s just the way things are.
On the flip side, I also agree that sharing everything meme-y we come up with is beneficial to the game and community in and of itself for a variety of reasons. Chief among them is new and interesting ways to enjoy our time with this game. But also some of the points @tqFan brought up: having a showcase of different possibilities opens avenues for creative thinking, discovering a quirk of the mechanics that may be buffed further down the line (or even a new and powerful combo that no one has foreseen so far)
I mean, it might also play different enough that some people would love this much more too. I have some skills I love using, and others I’d rather not… if you can find a way for me to play Primal strike without having to use Wind Devil, I’ll take it! It might not be as good, but if I can enjoy a playstyle without some of the downsides, it might be worth it to someone out there. (That’s just an example, I know there are a lot of Primal strike conversion out there)
That’s partly why I started that thread Once you start figuring out the game (Like I’m doing lately) thinking of the possibilities is a game in itself. I wanted to share that game within the game with others who might be interested, not only because I feel we need to have ALL TEH BUILDZ!
That said… once we get far enough in my thread, I know we’ll reach a point where only a few builds will be left, and they will be made using known formulas, with just the right conversions and tweaks… they will be nothing more than strictly inferior versions of something else made half-heartedly just to check a to-do list. At that point, the exercise will be much less interesting IMO. But until then, I’m making discoveries (I had no clue a pierce deceiver could be so good and tanky) and that’s what matters
I agree that most of these builds do not deserve their own thread, unless they stand out either through their gameplay, performance, visual or something else… Doing so would dilute the point of that forum section, which is to inform players.
At the same time, if we keep those funky builds in a single dedicated thread, we have that “rabbit hole” that people are free to jump into if they want, without clogging the tubes.