@jov :
well it was me said that legion shield is better than siegebreaker,
tbh i tested every situation with my current spec till now, just didnt went BoC which i didnt bother cause its easy place for this build anyway…
first of all, build naturally has %8 phys resist, 4 from shoulders 4 from oleron devotion, and min 1800 armor with %100 armor absorb, min %12 13 dmg absorb from bulwark + min 350 hp regen
in this case, highest dmg i have seen from flesh hulks are MAX 1.2 to 2k, well i have 2.2k DA so they have zero chance to crit… and any other hard phys hitters cant even get close to 2k direct hit. as being blademaster i have %15 avoid + %40 fumble from CoS aswell
fabius has 0.7 chance to crit me and his best shot was around 3k, didnt test iron maiden tho
so i see really ZERO reason to use that shield over legion shield… another things to mention is insane chaos and aether resist and %DA makes shield way toooooooooooooooooo good compare to legendary one… siegebreaker puts insane amount of pressure on gearing which we are already suffering so hard, and if i wanna sacrifice 1 slot for resist first candidate will be sheidl slot, since both has +1 soldier skill. dont wanna mention usless 1million pierce resist on it where build swims in pierce res already…
- 5 max pierce res + %19 phys res can ONLY make difference against mad queen, i am still not %100 sure but her basic attacks seems like phys + pierce mix…
conclusion, if i really want more protection against phys dmg in this setupwhich we dont for sure i would go good rolled rare shield even over siegebreaker
ya i would sacrifice +1 soldier skill even
i would only use that shield if i was a caster, tho its another topic balance between melee tanky specs and casters are abit disgusting in grim dawn atm…offtopic
tested both reaver claw specs
a) full pierce, well i didnt go so deep on this since i knew it will be not good as full phys setup,
clear speed is ok, slowd down on boss kill time and such
like i said going full pierce without dual blades nodes maxd and dual sword is kinda no ty.
b) %50 pierce + %50 phys
close to being same as warborn setup, but still performs like %85 90ish i would say…
conclusion, yeah full physical is way to go still.
about bmaster VS commando
cant be sure about final thoughts on this but if i would ever go demo over nightblade i would only go demo for 1 skill and its broken flashbangthis shit needs high cooldown or some nerf imo and mighty blast shield
i dont even count temper because its dmg is ok but i wouldnt care less, you can get same from 1 crushing ring + more cunning = done , temper is hugely out of my interest
the real battle for me is,
blast shield + flashbang+ OA from flametouched + vindictive flame aspeed
pburst + Cos + shadow dance + veil of shadow and maybe blade barrier
seems equal to me, maybe nightblade offers more defensive options.

time Blast shield and Overguard with her, go in and out a bit on her second spawn). If you still have problems play a bit with collosal grasp for Extra DA ti’ll you get the hang of it.