B30 Hotfix 1 (v0.3.7.5)

“Dismantling now has a small chance (higher with item quality) to generate Rare Crafting Materials (ex. Blood of Ch’thon) and a very low chance of generating a Skeleton Key.”

LOVE this change!!! How awesome! :smiley:

There can’t be a division by 0 but I didn’t really make an effort to make the equation easily readable (I think you are refering to the 2/piarctan which I should have written 2arctan/pi for clarity’s sake).
But you don’t have these nifty functions in your engine ? Madness ! I couldn’t live in a world without trigonometry and exponentiation :cry:. If I were you, I would start a riot and demand that someone in your team include them :stuck_out_tongue:

edit: Just make up your best act and scream: “I cannot work in these conditions !” and spill a dozen paperclips on the floor ! I am sure it would go well during the “last month” rush :stuck_out_tongue:

Did they really say this is coming, or are you just subtly reminding them that we need it :slight_smile:

do you guys have any intention of changing the current blueprint system?

Any chance we can get the drop rate on items fixed. It’s pretty hard to farm for items, when they never drop.

I understand it’s hard balancing out item drops, but I actually think there is a fundamental floor in how gd determines which item to drop and this needs to be investigated as a higher priority, (especially over balance changes in a single player game).

I know it will be hard to debug that entire drop system, but the game is not worth playing until its resolved.

This has clearly been happening for the last few builds given how the community is reacting.

Sent from my XT1068 using Tapatalk

Derp, sorry, my equation addled brain was thinking 100/(OA-DA) but it is in fact reverse order.

LOL. Sadly, this is my not-so-subtle reminder that we need it. I figure if I become annoying enough, they’ll either give it to me so I stfu, or outright ban me from the forums.

Also, can we get some skills that aren’t fucking “Lobs”. So tired of lobbing things. Why greater fireblast isn’t just a straight shot is beyond me. There are no reliable, non-lob, fire skills in the game right now. it seems like such an easy fix, too.

Was the dynamite drop rate increased? I’m doing Cronley runs right now and even common enemies are dropping it fairly often.

would it be better and easier to balance OA/DA through levels rather than stats on gear,attributes and devotion?

Evil Medierra, is that you? :eek:

Well, they upped it’s price quite a bit so finding more of it would certainly be nice…

Well, they upped it’s price quite a bit so finding more of it would certainly be nice…

I’m pleasantly surprised and glad that Crate had the balls to work around the two of the factors, which used to infest and disbalance most of the former and current games of this genre - AS and crit. These typically use to turn “the way to go” in any of the aRPGs I’ve played and ruined them balance wise.
It requires a huge pair to take the candy out from players with all the resistance and negative reviews, but to stand your right to balance the game properly.
I hope they’ll be able to execute it the right way.

What I didn’t get was the MS cap, as it’s an artificial way to slow down the progression, which reflects very negatively to classes with no movement skills involved, also provides the feeling of a clunky gameplay.
If there’s a hard cap set so low, then the basic MS got to be slightly increased, and slow effects to the player - greatly reduced, if not killed with fire.

Another concern is about the overall balance, related to the recent OA/DA changes and overall mob damage reduction, because there’s few time left to set it right.
Normal difficulty is in a good spot, but elite/ultimate went from moderately hard/overtuned, to piss off easy/moderately hard.
This yo-yo effect is concerning.

Hi Crate first of all keep up the good work. Now that this was said I would like to request the “+2 to Storm Totem” back on my Stormcage Legguards, I would really appreciate that.

I’m pleasantly surprised and glad that Crate had the balls to work around the two of the factors, which used to infest and disbalance most of the former and current games of this genre - AS and crit. These typically use to turn “the way to go” in any of the aRPGs I’ve played and ruined them balance wise.
It requires a huge pair to take the candy out from players with all the resistance and negative reviews, but to stand your right to balance the game properly.
I hope they’ll be able to execute it the right way.

There are no need to cap %AS. Same with OA. It was possible to solve both problem. They decided to cut the knot.

Yes ultimate is to easy now… And lot of monster need more hp

They did increase the base MS.

To be more clear. ARPG developer have three tools to reduce %AS effectiveness

  1. Dots. It’s damn too easy to remove some bonus physical damage from cadence and replace it by internal trauma.
  2. Cooldowns. For example, there are two many was said about Lethal Gambit: “Let’s make another skill without CD but with blue animation”. There are no need to do this. You can make spammable skill with short cd. Something like 1 second or 1.5 second. So it will work every 3 strikes with 100% attack speed. But it would not possible to increase proc rate by +%attack speed.
  3. Stat progression. If you have level 1 item then it can give +20% to damage or +10% attack speed. This will increase your damage almost equal. But level 50 item can give +60% to damage or +15% attack speed (power of one stat increased 3 times while another only 1.5 time). For example, if you look to Second Rite then it gives you only 95% to damage. If you compare this to +15% attack speed then it gives you 9.5% damage bonus if you have +900% chaos/vitality damage (without SR). 15% attack speed gives you 7.5% damage bonus if you have 200% attack speed. So, AS is not OP. It’s just matter of current numbers.
    Problem of AS that it increase all your instant damage from auto-attacks while +%damage affects only specific damage type. This comes to situation when some passives are too weak or they buffs too low amount of damage types. Recently was buffed Flame Touched. All main magical damage types was placed together. Ok. Now it’s possible to increase most of your damage by single passive. Same as with %AS. Moreover values was increased to be more relevant. Cool! (I did not understand why +flat fire damage was added but anyway). Now this is almost good example of good passive (ofc they will nerf it a bit because of this flat damage bonus).

Also attack/cast speed can be penalized by energy cost.

It should look like this:

  1. You have auto-attack build with big variety of damage types in it - pick %AS (same with cast speed). For example, something like maxed firestrike or PRM.
  2. You have combination of auto-attack and cooldown skills. But your damage focused on 1-2 damage types which synergy very good with each other. Then pick +%damage for this damage types. For example, Firestrike with only fire damage + BWC with transmuter + VF.
  3. You are focusing on skills with cooldowns. And these skills have big damage variation. Then you should focus on crit damage. Of course all attack skills with cooldown should have bonus to crit damage (but you need to find more on passives and devotion). For example, something with grenado, Canister bomb etc.
  4. If you have huge amount of dots in your damage then you need to find good balance between +%damage and +%attack/cast speed (for example, DEE)

So player should choose right gear for his build. Instead we have caps, nerfed stats, not balanced values on items etc.
Of course I do realize that reason is very small team size. Blaming balance is almost same like blaming graphics. For example it’s clear that team lacks of analyst which familiar with mathematics. Because most balanced changes are made by rolling balancing wheel. Primary skill of fire strike line is weakest but every build buffed static strike. Why? Because statistics showed that everyone used fire strike but noone uses static strike. So let’s buff static strike dispite the fact that primary skill is two times weaker already.

So, IMHO, it’s useless to whine about such final changes. We already recieved very good game. But it will not have good balance. Same as it will not have AAA grade graphics. Still balance is much better than it was in TQ made by larger team.

Even if it is a heck of new balance work I think diminishing returns when it comes to OA is the way to go. With fantasy numbers, as an example: Up to a difference of 500 between OA and DA there are no diminishing returns, giving a char a 25% crit chance (0.5% per 10 points). For the next 100 points it is 0.4% per 10 points, then, in 100 point steps, 0.3%, 0.2%, 0.1% and finally 0.05%.

So with a difference of 1000 between OA and DA a char would have a 36% chance to crit, and would be hard pressed to get it significantly higher.

They have diminishing return in their initial formula. They just needed to remove crit damage progression. For example, 1.1x crits start from 90%. 1.25x crits start from 100%. And player do not see higher crit values (or they start from big PTH, something like 1.5x crit from 140%)
Of course monsters should have own crit table.

I know, but it’s insufficient.

I’m not terribly good in theorycrafting, nor know the game mechanics in depth. More like empirically knowing the basics and whatever works. So cannot debate much on the various ways to balance, in details, but speak in general.
I’m aware there are other ways around. I’m also aware Crate took the path of the least resistance. What’s important for me if there’s a vision, the direction and the end results. The methods doesn’t bother me much.

From what I’ve experienced in other games, the lack of AS cap (or poorly implemented soft cap), and the importance of crit/crit mult for successful character development, bring severe balance issues. Like disparity between slow hitting high damage builds/no leech builds/low crit builds/CD builds and these on the other side of the spectrum - high AS/high crit (OA) builds, because they are affected to a much greater extent by leech/on-hit/on-crit procs, and at the end provide incomparably higher DPS and survivability. Finally they become the way to go and any different becomes a fail build, or at least a non-competitive one. Then developers begin to balance with strictly with AS/crit in mind and the former type of builds are hammered once again, or multiple times, or constantly.