that’s kinda what I had in mind. and soft caps are better than hard caps. /shrug
anyway, thanks for the response. 
that’s kinda what I had in mind. and soft caps are better than hard caps. /shrug
anyway, thanks for the response. 
Well I was finally able to kill Ultimate Fabius with my Warlock; although it took me about 10 tries to figure out how to play it, and also required me to shift points around my build to realize I needed maxed Blood of Dreeg and Armor of the Guardian. I also had to use all of the Royal Jelly pots and the OA pot, and a couple of gear swaps for better pierce resistance. But I did it. This was not possible at all in the previous patch.
Np
I’m still playing around with the formula, the problem is that the game is currently balanced around absolute differences in OA / DA. So a difference of 1000 OA above your opponents DA results in the same chance to hit / crit whether its 1500 vs. 500 or 3000 vs. 2000.
When I go to a more comparative formula, where I can have a fractional diminishing return, it shifts this to a consideration of ratio. In the above example, 1500 vs. 500 is now looked at as a 300% difference, and 4000 vs. 3000 is only a 150% difference. So for that to work and be balanced, we’d have to rebalance everything so that players and enemies would end up with a lot more OA relative to enemy DA to maintain equivalent hit / crit percentages. There are other undesirable side effects that could occur. It would certainly help bring crit chance under control but potentially not in a good way and I think it could make balancing even more difficult than it is now.
Maybe some convoluted Frankenstein hybrid formula could work… hmmm… That or maybe I just need to level up my maths
Did this fix the bug with LMB-assigned spells being broken with a skill disruption spell?
For anyone who doesn’t know, if you have a spell assigned to your LMB and get hit with any kind of spell disruption (ie. the green toxic cloud), you will alternate between casting the spell and melee attacks when holding down the LMB.
So if you’re buffing OA on gear and Devotion doesn’t that mean that Soldier and Arcanist will have even more of it and an even easier time getting it? Perhaps I’m missing something here…
Soldier and Arcanist are considered the two best Masteries due to both great defensive options AND OA increasers. The other Masteries being forced to play catch-up by using certain Devotions and gear (thus restricting their build and gearing choices) doesn’t seem particularly fair. OA is just too good; almost all builds want to stack it high.
I’m aware of this and it is being addressed. Some changes have already taken place that didn’t make it into the hotfix.
That said, while I want to even things out, the goal isn’t necessarily that every class should have equal opportunity to make a crit build. Ideally, I’d like to get the game into a place where builds aren’t suffering from lack of OA / DA but where it is also viable to just focus on boosting damage directly.
Have you perhaps considered a Devotion star that would remove crit but give 100% hit chance?
Woo, resolute technique?
Something along those lines hehe.
I mean if it was a Devotion constellation, let’s say mid-tier that you can activate by the end of Normal difficulty… could potentially enable much more build variety.
Basically leaving OA easier to balance since it’s more targeted towards crit and players who pick the constellation can ignore it, focusing only on flat/percentage damage increases.
Maybe not 100% but 90% or something. Depends on the theoretical damage output when you have no crit multipliers. If it’s too low, maybe have the constellation also give 33% chance of +100% total damage or whatever is needed… or just extra general increases to damage, maybe even attack/cast speed.
I think you meant aren’t, if so THANK YOU.
Since procs can be seen as a source of damage a really really good proc could warrant much lower stats on the item. This is trickier to balance though.
Some ideas to toss around for the OA/DA issue:
Is it possible to have hit bands, like in Pillars of Eternity? In it, you have “misses” that does 75%, 50% and 25% (IIRC) damage. However, it should only apply to players’ attack otherwise the value of DA will drop.
D&D4E and the 13th Age pen and paper RPGs has abilities that give +1 to hit or +1 crit chance (on a d20 dice) for each miss.
Perhaps for devotion, we can have a “soft crit” that doesn’t do additional damage, but could trigger Devotions/item procs? It could be an “excellent strike” or something and we can base procs off it.
chance to hit = 0.85+0.152/piarctan((OA-DA)/100)
chance to crit = 0.1+0.25*(1-exp((DA-OA)/300)) (or 0 if negative)
Here are some values, where x = OA - DA
x=-500 => cth = 0.72 ctc = 0
x=-200 => cth = 0.74 ctc = 0
x=-100 => cth = 0.77 ctc = 0
x=-14 => cth = 0.84 ctc = 0.09
x=0 => cth = 0.85 ctc = 0.1
x=14 => cth = 0.86 ctc = 0.11
x=100 => cth = 0.92 ctc = 0.17
x=200 => cth = 0.95 ctc = 0.22
x=500 => cth = 0.98 ctc = 0.30
The crit multiplicator threshold can stay as a dumby dumb dumb linear scaling.
These functions are good ol’ classics.
Arctan is excellent for switching between 2 values “linearly in the middle” (the switch values being 0.7 minimum hit chance and 1 maximum hit chance, can be tweaked easily if you absolutely want to attain 100% hit chance… or 95% for that matter :p)
Exponential is the definition of “yeah, we really don’t want you to go beyond this number” (the max crit value being 35% in this particular equation and again, easily tweakable)
edit: I chose this numbers because you seem to have originally intended that 14 OA = 1% hit/crit.
Does the latter sentence imply every class could make a hit-build?
I’ll play naked just for you !
Maybe it would be a good idea to remove the OA from the Soldier and Arcanist skills as many have suggested but instead tie them to invested attribute points in Cunning and Spirit (not Cunning or Spirit gained from skills or items). This would make putting points in Cunning and Spirit more attractive (necessary?) for all builds no mater what Mastery they are based upon. It never really seemed fair to me that some Masterys can excel by putting all their attribute points into just one attribute (Physique) while others must invest significant amounts in multiple attributes.
Flat or % to OA and DA could also be added or increased on items as has been mentioned by the Devs.
One other thing I’ve considered is making +%crit dmg bonus a multiplier of the innate crit dmg bonus, instead of additive. As it is now, straight adding to the crit multiplier, it is just as effective if you score a tier1 crit vs. a tier5 crit. That would make +%crit dmg only become really powerful on a focused crit build.
This runs into the potential issue though where, if something is OP but hard to accomplish, players will sacrifice everything else to achieve it and it, making it the sole focus of the game. If its hard to accomplish but not quite powerful enough to justify doing so, then no one will bother with it and it becomes a useless mechanic. The sweet spot between the two may be a razors edge where it is impossible to get just the right balance.
A solution to that problem is making it situational but that can be tricky too. Currently it is sort of situational because it is most effective to focus on a crit build using Soldier and / or Arcanist but, because it’s so powerful, it leaves people feeling that builds without at least one of those masteries are underpowered…
Waiting on that castable Chain Lightning Hotfix. It’s going to feel so good when it rears its helpful head. I’ll finally be able to shut the hell up.
I was there when this was suggested!
Great turn-around rate, Crate. The amount of time and effort that the devs put in to fix problems and balance things is phenomenal. I really hope people appreciate how responsive and compromising the devs actually are.
Me too! 
I appreciate the suggestion. Would be cool if we had all those functions built into the engine but alas, we do not. PTH and Crit are both determined by one formula currently - probably would have been easier had I split them but I think I can get things into reasonable balance the way it is. Also, not hard to fix but your formula could result in division by zero.