don’t be sorry for the idea/or having an idea itself, that’s not my intent for making a counter perspective/argument.
For me, personally/selfish, i like this weapon/have had fun with it, and to me the only “bad” part is, it’s effectively an MI exclusive to end by being locked off to secret level
(i think we even suggested to somehow make it accessible to levelling at some point since that could be fun)
It being a 2h SS makes it slightly unique (imo) because 2h NB builds feel slightly different(/and all SS mods are on 1h), so personally i don’t want to potentially lose that.
And i also feel like not being endgame competitive is something that applies to many items, so suggesting to add or buff is better than removal if performance is the basis.
this was a really fun build, (and way better than my own memes),
and the halberd can even be used (even if poorly) for meme Shadow Strike.
So it’s simply that i like something that this suggestion would remove, that makes me disagree with the delivery.
I’m not in anyway trying to dissuade suggestions or trying to act like you/users can’t come with them, just that i disagree on the solution, (even if by disagreeing it comes off as me asserting myself “above”).
Suppose you could say my delivery of my counter argument/disagreeing makes it appear worse than intended to, in essence it’s just there to make the opposite view/opinion put out there. That way if it does get removed, atleast it was tried to be “saved” 
- since in the end devs are the ones deciding the item fates, not whether I “disagree” on it or not