Skill tier list [1.3.1.2]

As I am torn about some of the great/ OP skills being OP and would be more restrained on that topic (some can and others can’t), I agree with he general feel on most skill described.

Just one utility skill I don’t fully agree with is Soul Siphon. In a build that has some mods for it as well (duration + damage even + charge), It’s basically an instant full HP heal in that very second and countinuses to heal full HP as it ticks every second.

Has big AoE at high rank and with mods it will decently eat away at trash mobs while making you unkillable short of 1shot bursts from an enemy.

That being said, I’d like some of the damage or Dot mods at least to be stronger and to find more + skills for it on misc gear or dedicated. Also more Blood Boil for the DA shred. Necro needs the defense.

I’d like to express my personal hatred towards Ill omen at 10/10 lasting exactly as long as its CD is. It’s actually lower than CD anywhere below that, meaning you need to cast one of the worst skills in the game with no visual candy to it on cooldown, interrupting whatever was the cool thing you’d rather be doing. Just to watch the monsters turn around and fuck off away from you. Probably due to boredom.

5 Likes

Well it’s just when your single target is lower than on the top melees but you are still a melee it can be a problem. Ranged has huge mods and volley wps to fall back on, plus obscene speeds and well, advantage of having range. Melee Cadence against bosses is just a melee build with mediocre single target damage and inconsistent leech.

Putting aside the futility of throwing around words like “just throw out the skill and redo it again, but better” and expecting developers to understand what on Earth you mean, I’m still holding out hope of turning OFF into a teleport skill like that feedback thread asked (sorry, I forget the name of the OP).

If burly warriors like Oathkeepers and Berserkers can have built-in movement skills, arcane mages can have their teleports. Especially since Arcanists don’t have access to the usual support option of having baked-in RR.

agree, main problem is no feasible 2h damage mods (so tooltip floats around 60k which is unacceptable for 2h). maybe sth like Korvan Halberds’ builds are decent but haven’t seen them in ages.

fumble immunity is probably the best thing about it. some support is lacking/outdated, imo (like Arcanor for 3-ele fw but we all know 3-ele struggles big times anyway).

It’s kinda bad even with trillion TDM from conduit/dreadwalker set (for solo damage). AoE/shotgun is also volatile: you may either delete everyone and their mum in 2 sec or barely scratch 'em. Probably flat cd duration should be increased a bit on the skill itself.

chances for it are indeed nowhere to be found (only on aether 1h arbalest afaik but that still has very limited use), no passthru, no feasible mods whatsoever.

not to mention we have like 3 sets supporting the skill and only 1 (Light Defender) has extra area to it but I imagine it is nowhere near Stormserpent. and then there’s also vitality SJ that have 2 mods, zero ranks and zero dps.

tried it as vileblade and cold breaker, the damage wasn’t there. even with resets and pretty big flat and dot it hits like awet noodle in a very small area.

a movement skill. I tried chaos with both armageddon sword and Umbra’dol spear and DAR/Vire interaction is the most painful thing you can imagine. also it had zero damage, obviously.

and to tell the truth, even that 200% tdm wasn’t enough to propel the build into top category, it just made it decent. I wish we really had all those acid/poison mods baked into the set/shield and sword and then got conduit reworked and etc etc. and buff baseline skill with that 200% tdm, it really can’t go wrong.

the area should be increasing with level, node area should be increased as well. damage I didn’t even notice.

and you forgot the mighty Blade Barrier. it’s like mirror but worse. somehow it has retal mods but no ranks whatsoever and almost no usage, maybe only as a 1-pointer on some fringe nb builds. I’d say it needs a rework.

2 Likes

To everyone talking about utility, just keep in mind that this is first and foremost a damage tier list cause, as banana said, it’s gonna be really hard to make a total tier list with everything taken into full account.

Not saying you can’t talk utility, just saying cause I personally don’t wanna see this devolve into that devotion thread by doomgod.

1 Like

Playing runekeeper or reaver, you just can’t catch a break these days. Already nerfed, now asking for more nerfs…

As always, nobody likes their build getting nerfed, everyone likes their builds getting buffed.

I haven’t been on the forum long enough to know how Crate judge these opinionated skill tier list but hopefully they manage to buff what they think is under-performing rather than the other way around.

Excellent tier list in my opinion, it aligns pretty well with my own experience on the classes I’ve been playing. My only gripe with the game at this point is that some skills (Vines, Gandarr, Wendigo …) seem a bit outdated or hard to justify investing into !

2 Likes

1.3.2 or 1.3.1.2?

yeah, i started missing 1. for some reason

Oh yeah duh! You’re so right lol. You could buff player damage on reap spirit by 50% and it won’t break anything. Wasn’t looking at it that way

What if it tethered not just to you, but other enemies with Storm Box on them :thinking:

Also, there are no items with modifiers for Lightning Tether. The tech exists now, would be nice to see.

1 Like

These skills could be higher in the ultimate tier list. This is primarily for dmg, and for dmg both skills are very bad. I never feel good about investing anything into Siphon Souls. Last few builds I did with it I ended up 2-pointing it. Yes, it can be satisfying to clear trash with this button press. But a lot of stuff does that right now, and against everything hero+ Siphon does close to nothing. Also never feel a substantial tank from it. It can only leech to full vs a huge pack of trash, and any filler with decent WD% can do that.

Keep in mind, the thread is in the “classes, skills and builds” folder, not in “ideas and feedback”. It’s not a nerf-buff call for devs type of tier list, except the tier 5 skills that i do strongly believe need to be reworked. If the design decision is for Devouring Swarm to have this low dmg, it will be in tier 4 in this ranking, and there’s no tragedy in that.

3 Likes

The post that you quoted was tongue-in-cheek, pinball’s not being serious here.

It depends on whether the nerf is “my Callagdra times went from 1:00 to 2:00” or “my Callagdra times went from 1:00 to 20:00 (twenty)”. Crate doesn’t do the latter set of nerfs at all unless if it’s to fix a very obvious exploit, and even then, the complainers don’t come back when a future patch revisits & buffs the same thing that was “destroyed” and returns to a reasonable power level.

They have posted here before something akin to “why bother with a build that can beat the hardest superbosses in 2 minutes when I can play a build that can beat it in 30 seconds?” And remember that these are bosses of the most challenging content - we’re talking about the difference between beating Ascendant mode dungeon bosses in 5 seconds vs 15 seconds; seriously, a 10 second difference should not be causing emotional palpitations in people.

The tier list in the OP is largely sound; my only gripe is that the skills that only require 1 node to max out like Storm Totem should have some bonus points in the tier list compared to skills that require 3-4 nodes to max out and still have middling results. Yes, Mortar Trap and Storm Totem are functionally the same thing, but Mortar Trap is 100% more difficult to put together because of how many different skill bonuses you need to max out, so Storm Totem should at least be a tier above Mortar Trap unless Mortar Trap does 3X more damage than Storm Totem does.

2 Likes

The point about Nightblade WPS (except for Execution) is well made. I think Belgo Shears, AQC and Whirling Death are amongst the skills that have been left behind in FoA and which are no longer competitive. You feel this if you want to make a melee Sabo, Witch Hunter, Spellbreaker or any class where the Nightblade has sole responsibility for bringing the WPS.

I think this may get overlooked simply because Nightblade is over all a strong mastery, one half of Reaver etc. Not everything about it is currently good.

1 Like

Before you read anything else that comes after, I just want to thank you @banana_peel for this list, which seems, for the most part, an accurate representation of the state of things, and at the very least a way to crystalize the ideas in people’s minds and to give us a common starting point for discussion. Great job on that :slight_smile:

That being said, if this list (and you) is not open to slight changes as other players bring in their opinion, and would be a more accurate view of the consensus (what sucks for one player might have some unperceived benefits for other players after all) then I think it would be wasted effort, so I hope you consider some of this feedback and adjust your list accordingly.

if this list is meant as YOUR opinion, then feel free to ignore what comes next.

But overall, please don’t take this as a criticism of your work, but rather an attempt to contribute and build on it :slight_smile:

Here’s my take on some of those skills that I believe I have a bit more experience with than most.

I’ve completed the game with literally nothing but Devouring swarm. Yes, it requires gear mods to be effective, but for the small investment you have to put in, it’s at least decent. I think it deserves to be tier 3 (Or at least not to share the same spot with Word of pain…)

Same deal here (just a grimtool link, no forum post) I’ve dome a few passivist runs with blade spirit, using demonslayer and chillwhisper, and they were ok. But Bloodmane + scarab shell makes a very effective and very safe build that (I think) should earn it a spot higher in the tier list. BS is infinitely more effective a PSP than wind devil or GoE, and they should not share a tier. Whether that means that they should go down a tier, or that BS should move up is up to your standards, but they don’t belong in the same spot IMO.

I think you’re giving it too much credit. This is a 3-node skill that struggles to kill trash mobs, brings few other benefits, and is a helm and conduit away from being overtaken by war cry…
Even when capped and boosted by a set, it’s barely useful beyond the cooldown reset
This is, IMO, the second worst skill in the game next to Storm box. How it snuck into tier 4 is strange to me.

It can and it does. It’s even easy to pilot and very safe.

Agreed with everything there however.

I think overall it’s not as abysmal as the others, and deserves to be moved up a tier.

I really tried to make this work as a main damage skill. I tried Cinderborn + colossal fortress, I tried Agrivix, I tried Dauntless…
I’m not disagreeing with you here: I just want to point out how bad it is and how warranted its spot it…

1 Like

It has less personality but I always thought it’d be simpler if you summon an unkillable totem that expires and the damage comes entirely from the tether between you and your totems.

You mentioned the mods are timid, so for some damage types that’s probably the issue.

Cold siphon on Zakull on the other hand has both Damage and 15% heal mod added to it, which translates into even more heal at 39% of the damage done here
image.

So you only need just a couple of mobs. And if RR is applied one can be enough and it also countered the side effect of Sanginis really well.

Notice instant full heal 3 sconds in vs 2 trash mob. But, this is a good set. So as far as utility goes, if all damage types could have a good level of use out of it and abough + skills on gear so that it is not so taxing to max, it could be great on the tier list

My personal idea of a fix for SBoE would be to remove the targeting entirely: just automatically affect and tether everything that comes within a certain distance (up to the maximum number of targets)

Other than the damage, SBoE’s biggest issue is that it’s awkward to use and has a weird cooldown that’s too long for the damage it does, but that’s not worth the time to press buttons for it if you lower the cooldown…

1 Like

The set also has heal proc on full bonus with 0.5 cd. What i suggest for you to do is play your usual modes with the set and then play the same modes but not using Siphon whatsoever. I sometimes was forgetting to press Siphon on my Zakull build and tbh didn’t notice any dmg or tank loss.