I had a similar idea where it would essentially be a self buff that automatically latches onto targets within range up to a limit of three with a brief cooldown in between latches. Mods like Allagast would be able to reduce the delay between latching so you’re just a walking lightning rod constantly zapping everything.
One of many possible issues of that would be it ceases to function as a skill proccer since it’s a self-buff. Also questionable whether or not it would then be able to apply -%RR effects, as that’s not exactly something you can put on a self-buff unless it’s a damaging aura a la Veil of Shadow. It would probably end up being some sort of “secondary effect” on an aura like Ulzuin’s Wrath is and that becomes all sorts of messy when it comes to item skill modification. Maybe a simpler solution would be for it to function as is except it jumps onto another target if the first one dies before the duration expires. Then the question is whether or not something like that can even be done in the engine, carrying over duration and all that. At most we have spreading mechanics like Pox but those start a new duration each jump.
Speaking of jumps, as someone else mentioned…Ill Omen. Not a fan of the fact its one possible damage-focused application (Morgoneth) had it stripped but more so, the fact the thing lasts about as long as its cooldown if you max it (unless you have CDR) and doesn’t cast into space but onto a target makes it just heinous to use. If it’s not going to be a damaging skill, fine. Not sure why then there’s a lifesteal mod for it on Dreamwalker, but ok. But it could really use like double duration or something. DR sources are always welcome, but that means the poor user-friendliness of the skill is constantly on display whenever you’re Necromancing.
Was gonna hop onto the bandwagon when it comes to Blade Trap and OFF but the truth is it’s been so long since I’ve touched either I probably shouldn’t comment just yet. One thing that always irks me with OFF (other than the obvious) is its baked-in Fire and Physical resistance reduction, only for literally all OFF itemisation outside of Mageslayer to be trying to build it as a Cold skill and add cold RR. We’ve got all this weird stuff with Fleshwarped Casque, Decree of the Circle of Five and Aetherscorched Cleaver trying to push for perhaps some sort of physical Battlemage and yet when you’d want to try to make use of a massive RR source (assuming it even works on your target) none of the gear supports you. Wradlith, Night’s Embrace active skill, Spectral Bludgeon, everything goes cold so that phys RR goes unused. I’ll add also that if OFF and Blade Trap are ever supposed to be useful, then act bosses and superbosses need to lose those damn 500% CC resistances. Bring them down to Nemesis level. Both BT and OFF have some massive debuff effects, it’s understandable you should only get to capitalise on them for a few brief moments lest they be broken, but having them do literally nothing against targets like the Dread is absolute overkill.
Nobody really uses it but Dreamwalker also gets a lot of damage on it.
OFF is so close to be good… all it needs is a MASSIVE frostburn buff to absolute zero so that even if you don’t freeze your target you at least have something out of it. Make it work with Onslaught, and introduce a few pieces of gear that push the frostburn damage and you have something soldi that’s both crowd control… but also doesn’t become completely uiseless against bosses.
Lowkey, this is the only T1 I feel could use some form of tuning down in its itemization nerfed into T2 territory. I don’t think the highest mobility builds should also be top DPS. That being said, it’s pretty fun.
Tho… I also loathe that the T1s and T2s are full of WPS now. My first intuition is that WPS get too much AoE from modifiers. They should probably come with negative TDM or something.
Primary target still took full dmg, secondary targets should only recieved 50%.
However I think it wouldnt solve the problem, when a build with just 3 buttons deals insane dmg and high mobility vs piano build only scratches mobs. Low effort but massive payoff.
I don’t think it would solve the problem either but GD is not going to be a game where piano builds compete anyway. My issue is more that 100% WPS skill builds make single skill nodes top tier in the current meta, outcompeting spells that require +skills to 3 skill nodes. Just feels wrong to me.
And I don’t think the answer is to make all the spells stronger (though some could use more support via ascended affixes or skill modifiers) because WPS builds are already pushing the boundary of what I think is unhealthy DPS.
I think having WPS builds have either very strong single target but no AoE, or a negative modifier for AoE, is healthier.
Have to notice here: only some bosses. Typically a human or human sized. Most big monster bosses have 500% trap res. This skill was useless meme for years.
Oh, yeah. I am probably one person on this forum who use this skill (very from time to time though) as 1-pointer . It’s worse then any emergency proc in the game. And when I actually use it I just prey that there will be no sunder attack incoming. I suggested to make it immune to sunder while it active so you don’t get oneshotted right after skill ends, but this skill is so unpopular so nobody doesn’t even care I suppose.
it was useless for years because it didn’t have innate cc shred
While i can’t say it for certain/“numbers wise”, anecdotally playing an OFF+Trap spellbreaker, it seemed like there was more enemies/bosses susceptible to trap than OFF, and not just the human/small size ones, and at the time checking GT seemed like on avg most had slightly less trap res than free
^Titanvore (common trend seemed to be that 98-118 spread or straight 133 like nemesis or 500 outright ofc)
*that’s not me saying it’s good or great now, just that “on avg”, to me, it seemed like it was slightly more useful than OFF in activity (after CC res shred change ofc)
on that note
enemies are not affected by Absolute Zero/frostburn if still can’t initially be frozen
dude, why, it was off the mark for so long. it’s finally nice. Man, come what may but, whenever we’re given what we ask for, we become disenchanted with the whole thing.
I wrote ‘typically’ for a reason. Of course you may find some exceptions. My point is, it still not even every usual boss, and all superbosses are totally immune. So yeah, still meme, -10-20-whatever % trap res won’t change much here. Even against vulnerable targets this skill doesn’t give much. May be % reduced targets damage against immune mobs or just in general will make this skill a bit better.
As long as the effect lasts more than zero seconds, it would be enough to apply a DoT, which could run its course for its whole duration regardless of the freeze.
Pretty sure Absolute Zero is only applied if the enemy is frozen. I just think they should get rid of full freeze immunity. Make some enemies be just above the cap so you need OFF or some other means to make them freezable for at least a brief period.
OFF can’t even proc devotions against some enemies. It’s all or nothing currently.
yes, absolute zero is a regular modifier, the RR is ofc tied to freeze duration in full as it’s part of the base debuff, but the frostburn is still added to the debuff, so the initial debuff still needs to be able to trigger for a split second to apply the frostburn (even if frostburn has its own duration+extension, it needs the initial hit passing).
Krieg phase2 is always a great reminder of how useless OFF “in full” becomes out of nowhere with a “slight” CC res change
this, the frostburn itself can’t proc anything, only the debuff tick, that means initial hit or subsequent freeze duration ticks is the part that can proc stuff. Freeze immune enemies (krieg p2 test) wont even trigger a devo at 100% proc chance ofc, and procs drop off in frequency the faster they are unfrozen
curiously, with FoA tech (fault line/hailstorm) affecting how some secondary effects work, i wonder if it’s possible to turn Absolute Zero into a second effect that’s then separate from the main skill in application requirement
I think that skills that are fun should also be strong. That’s part of what makes a game good. One should never trade off fun for power. And Shadow Strike is a lot of fun (as you said yourself).
Again, stop treating the list as a nerf-buff plea. In my opinion, there are curerntly zero OP skills at their baseline. Zero.
And this state of the game is very natural for the balance process we currently have: when OP builds pop up, they are easily reported and promptly nerfed. While buffing or reworking an entire skill is a much harder task, so some UP things exist in the game indefinitely.
All tier 1 and tier 2 are rather close in power. Some AA and WPS mods can be trimmed down a little bit. But a lot of WPS are among t1 and t2 not because they are OP, but because they are in a good state. For reference, this is roughly the graph of skill power right now:
Sure, I just don’t think it should be one of the tippy top strongest. If you nerfed its end game by 5-10%, it’ll still be good. I said bring it down to T2, which are all also strong.
What’s the alternative? Attempt to make the SS builds squishier? Ok, I would agree that can also work. But past a certain level of squishiness they just become frustrating to play in ascendant.
I didn’t, I simply gave my opinion.
That’s what I’m suggesting though? Why does my thought of nerfing them need to be read as obliterate? A trim here and there is all I had in mind.
I understand the curve you presented but is it not odd that single skill node WPS have displaced multi-skill-node abilities as top DPS? Invest less skill points to deal more damage? Is that good? I’m just not sure.
Ofc you can’t look at WPS in a vacuum because part of their power is stacking them on top of a DAR. So that’s a bit more complex. Because then it can sort of be viewed as investing in 4 skill nodes. The 3 DAR nodes + capping the WPS.
Whereas spammy spells just don’t have the ability to be stacked with another skill.
I also actually kind of accept that since melee is more RIPPy than ranged casting, that perhaps it’s fine that GD turns the whole casters doing more damage stereotype on its head.
You mean the base skills independent of skill modifiers? I agree with that. I should have clarified the only nerfs I can imagine for them would occur at the itemization level.