Skill tier list [1.3.1.2]

Idk, if you want the sentiment of “trim the mods a bit here and there” come across, don’t be so dramatic:

the description is on point. But you can proc even summons with it …huge btw here

I meant I loathe that they’ve outclassed so many other types of skills in terms of damage. Not that they should be obliterated. The pattern of so many WPS skills being at the very top of the list does invite scrutiny. Me loathing their dominance doesn’t mean I think they should be reduced far far down.

It remains to be seen where the meta lands. Do mixed WPS builds mostly disappear? That seems like a shame. Will the next top 20 list have more than half of its builds include a 100% WPS? We just don’t know yet, but your tier list to me begs the questions.

Loathe was a poor choice of words. It’s not a big deal. I just want to see a more of a mixed bag at the top, and I feel very strongly about that.

I feel like everyone is very on edge about game balance these days. I don’t really feel like walking on eggshells or putting too much caution into how I word things out of concern it might… Upset people on the internet who disagree. But I accept the criticism that I should have been more precise.

4 Likes

Currently strongest auto-attackers do not have 100% of one* wps, most of them at least.

Then don’t, unless you are a street performer. Where did you even find them? You said smth, I disagreed, you specified what you meant, we move on, everything is good.

No. Most of builds I play rn aren’t 100% but rather two WPS with one being main. There is a small problem in several cases where a build can get 100% of one uberstacked WPS through 10-13 ascends and be a very expensive but a boring best version of itself.

I’m not sure how you battle it. One way is to make a hardcap for WPS at 75% or smth. Another is to balance all WPS to the point where they are doing very similar dmg. The first one sounds better.

Again, I wouldn’t put it as “outclassed”. Let’s examine the list. First, we set aside the entire tier 5 that consists of a small selection of skills completely out of whack in terms of balance, and assume they’ll be buffed or reworked at some point in the future. Let’s take tiers 1-4 with the majority of skills, each one is at least playable.

WPS:
3 in tier 1, 7 in tier 2, 3 in tier 3, 5 in tier 4. And most of the granted WPS that are always a part of AA build equation will be tier 3-4.

In comparison, a big cooldown nuke skill playstyle:
2 in tier 1, 5 in tier 2, 6 or 7 in tier 3, 6 in tier 4

Doesn’t look like WPS completely dominate the field from this statistic. You have to remember that most skills in the list are their own builds, while for WPS and AA entries - builds usually involve 3 of those. So the list is visually bloated with WPS, not representing the volume of associated builds.

Another note: I am absolutely confident I can take ANY dmg type AAR and roll over the game. Almost the same applies to Grenado. I absolutely cannot do it with any dmg type Savagery. There are so many Savagery builds that are atrocious. But the list only respects “best in class” builds. Need to keep that in mind as well.

6 Likes

Oh, that’s good to hear! But as how to deal with the few cases of Uberstacked outliers, I also have no idea. Also like I said, if it’s not overly prevalent I’m not even convinced it’s a problem. It depends on how strong they are relative to everything else I think.

I concur on some of the forum reactions to stuff, including my own, being too kneejerky at times. I thought about it more and realized that with these new added vectors of power, potions, ascended bonuses, cooldown refreshers, charges, onslaught, etc. it’s sort of only natural that the new outliers be even bigger outliers than we’ve seen before. And there will be cases where it’ll be hard to tune something cool and specific without homogenizing other stuff. I leave it to big Z.

As for the rest of your post, thanks for laying all that out. Very illuminating, well argued points, I’m seeing what you mean. So yeah it’s probably more fine than I worried about.

This in particular was like a lightbulb going off for me.

Regarding AAR, I was going to suggest an acid AAR set since every single other damage type is, indeed, very well supported. Cold AAR was the only one that directly exists where I couldn’t find a “feels good to play” version of it. All the rest were fun. But also there hasn’t been that much tinkering with the cold approach so probably a lot of room for optimization.

So green AAR is the only one that doesn’t exist. While other skills probably deserve more variety and support, I just think it’d be hilarious to complete the AAR collection of great builds hahaha.

1 Like

I think it’s also worth noting that WPS builds only really get super strong with a good DAR, and those are typically a 3 node skill themselves. WPSes are effectively the 4th, 5th node of a DAR skill.

And while 100% single WPS build outcompeting a multiple WPS build might seem wrong from a skill-point perspective, it makes sense from a ascended affix slot perspective. You are sacrificing a ton of stats on those slots just to get additional proc chances, sometimes to the point that it’s not actually worth going for a single 100% WPS.

Thankfully you are Not a game designer.
It does feel though you are one of those people when going to a party and seeing everyone having fun, they cant have that and you feel obliged to ruin it.

10 years later SS is finally where it should be - powerful with the right setup and at the right cost.
It is in no way OP the way you make it be wow.

It has a huge CD, it requires your whole build to be centered around it including massive skill point investment + itemisation which is very limited.

It is not a “i win” button and it requires some sensible level of playskill to not get your self instagibbed.
Also SS builds are glass cannons.

1 Like

So hostile… did you miss the part where I heard banana out and conceded? Part of the reason for discourse is to get user input fleshed out more. I give my opinions with the expectation of pushback, especially when people have better information than I do on stuff I’m getting wrong. My heels are never dug in on what I write; I chime in to fish for more information. Since I have limited time to build characters, talking it out with people here in a few posts can save me many hours of building a character or multiple versions of a build to test something, assuming what they present makes sense to me. It’s nice and collaborative. I am aware Zakull has been somewhat tuned down from the onslaught and berserker nerfs already.

I have a ways to go before my own Zakull character is finished. I haven’t seen any other SS builds that look unreasonable.

To simplify my take, which you’re free to disagree with, is that I don’t think SS should end up being a top SR farmer unless it’s pretty risky/squishy. I do think it should be the top MI farmer due to its mobility.

1 Like

I disagree with doomgod’s initial take and he already retracted his statement, but let’s also not pretend that ss takes skill. Especially current ss. It’s basically a one button build excluding rr (if your 2nd class has active rr). Maybe you have ABB for lethal, which you only press every 8 seconds. Your main attack is also your moveskill. And you’re not gonna have a lack of moveskills even if you spam ss because resets galore and you still have evade + movement rune.

SS is infinitely easier to play than all piano builds out there and it’s even easier than normal melee cause of all the mobility.

I dunno if OP agrees but, my feeling is that the skill tier could be simplified into two big tiers

  • AA builds (aided by the % WPS change, even after the 1.3.1 nerf) or spells with nero zero upkeep, typically aided by a cooldown-reduction mechanic post-1.3
  • Rest

I feel that some older-style build approaches with 2x main spells or 1x main speel+autoattack for fill-up have fallen behind.

IMO, CDR tied to ascendancies or even WD to underwhelming spells/player pets tied to ascendancies could breathe some fresh air

Acid AAR set wouldn’t hurt. Right now you can do it with the Occultist green amulet, just converting everything globally. It’s ugly but somewhat works cause of very high crit and oa:

2 Likes

Thanks 4 share.

Yes please! Been wanting this since forever :rofl:

1 Like

others have asked for years aswell Albrecht'S Aether Ray - Acid / Bleeding Type Conversion? (actually i think it’s Sin’s sole and biggest wish through the years to get that sweet toxic green lazor :sweat_smile:)

1 Like

looks at skill conversion spreadsheet, sees the near full list of AAR convos, scrolls up to see like 15 skills wishing they had as many conversion options as AAR, cries

why does it have to suffer for being fast?

It simply does what it advertisesand it’s fun for it

Vire is a mobility skill and it’s pretty bad. Like SS I don’t think it should suffer for it’s practical use.

And SS was in a mediocre spot for a long time.

2 Likes

It doesn’t have to. I just personally think the game is more interesting with such trade offs. Like how you can give up DPS to build tankier. Roughly speaking, Speed, durability, single target dps, and AoE tend to be the big measures of a build, and usually when a build gets one to an extreme, it pays for it in at least one other place.

I agree SS is in a way better place than it’s been in a long time. I am not suggesting reverting it back there. If you took the best SS build rn and nerf it’s DPS 5%, I think it’d still be very fun. I am not currently advocating for it because I haven’t tested it enough, I am merely raising the considerations I have.

I agree Vire’s has been in a bad state for a while I think needs a good deal of love.

Yes, that’s what would make its addition to the game particularly funny. And it’d likely be well received since people love AAR. :joy:

God do I feel this. It’s a skill that does decently to well in Campaign, SR and Crucible even if it struggles to keep up when you’re going fast. But it’s miserable when fighting superbosses that move a lot and can’t be tanked.

Can someone enlightent me any giga AAR build as I cant find one.