TDM on both Amplicorum and Sanginis is not healthy for the game

It is skewing build performance toward builds that can get away with using both.
I also wholly agree with @xervous that the ability to siphon defensive stats into offensive power is generally bad for the game and muddies build archetype identities…

I’d go so far as to say potion strength in general is a bit out of whack. It might be extreme to say we’re building around potions instead of having potions be something nice we can add to builds, but they’re so impactful that it doesn’t feel far off.

I know I’ll probably eat hellfire from the community for this, but I’d like to see the buffs from potions play a more minor role in the game when it comes to combat. Certainly less than they are now. The damage reduction potion feels fine to me because of its short duration and thus need to use it very reactively and the inability to count on it to bail you out of prolonged skirmishes.

It’s possible the numbers on the buffs themselves are fine and it’s just that Sanginis and Amplicorum last far too long.

Guys, this is just my opinion; please be civil.

17 Likes

Max speed potion did nothing wrong

Aside from phys damage outliers, a 24k hp build with amplicorum is a 20k hp build with 12% TDM. If we look at “Of Vitality” suffixes as a point of reference, is a suffix worth >4% global TDM?

1 Like

I’ve written a lot about these potions here:

The point I’m making now is the same one I made then: when a large quantity of monsters have a 3-5 second delay before they use their most dangerous attacks, large multipliers like TDM potions is a huge boon for survivability instead of a malus modifier.

Nobody cares that an enemy is now doing 20%, 50% or even 100% more with its basic attack if it’s dead before it can use the attack that’s actually dangerous to the player. It widens the discrepancy between “skills that do tons of damage” & “skills that are weak that need buffs” a hundred fold and all these potions accomplish is muddy the waters on how much adjusting these skills really need to make it in endgame.

6 Likes

Oh yeah as someone who makes Grim Dawn builds sometimes I am always building with Amplicorum in mind nowadays, that’s not even a question or a choice. You just have to build enough defenses to use the potion. I find Sanginis to be more annoying but if you think about it: in a meta when main danger is not being overwhelmed but rather being one shot Sanginis should be a safer choice (I guess it might be harder to counter for some builds).

2 Likes

Randumb thought: rework one of the TDM pots to just grant a fat stack of onslaught charges

  • not all builds will want it
  • it’s not something you just push and forget about
2 Likes

Potion mods should have been just used as alternatives to plug holes in builds, like help alleviate mana issues, or add some more bulk through a damage absorption shield.

7 Likes

Sanginis is more of less ok, I think. It gives damage but the cost is also insane, I don’t wanna use it even on highly hp restored chars.

Amplicorum is another story. I think it’s better just to give this modificator to all potions in general and that’s it. Many builds needs this damage, including builds what far cry from being OP, but I am afraid if community will proceed complain about it, Crates just nerf it to non-playable level.

1 Like

This is a really REALLY good point. There are many cases where the damage improvement is effectively boosting your survivability, not hurting it, because it lets some builds finish threats off before they can reach you, before they can use a killer move, before your buffs/procs go on cooldown, etc.

1 Like

Amplicorum should be nerfed to unplayable, if not changed. It forever benefits the strongest builds, better to salvage the lesser builds by targeted buffs.

7 Likes

I do think we need to note that we’re not trading 1 suffix for 4%tdm, we’re trading one suffix and a potion slot. And that potion slot itself is worth like 40% armor or 50%hp barrier etc.

Not to say that amplicorum isn’t good, but the opportunity cost is more than just its own incoming damage amp.

2 Likes

This - if you are in the ultra extreme min maxing group of gdstasher who are mostly the ones who have borderless access to eh a min/maxed build - why would you care if your “ravager kill time” is 5 sec more or less…

For the bulk of normal players, not gdstashing - it is quite difficult to build around the penalties after latest patch.
12% Total damage Received is HUGE in Ascendant, fully juiced altar etc.
10% of your Total HP Per Second drain - is Huge.

The benefits are what 10% more DPS? Come on unless you absolutely wet yourself of some dummy kill times - yes it does make an impact but for the rest of the game it is now quite balanced.

After 1.3.1 i actually replaced Amplicorum on many of my builds with the Dmg shield or just buffed Armor - damage loss is really not felt.

So to OP my suggestion is to try to look at such topics outside of the gdstasher vacuum chamber as well.

1 Like

How about stop being rude and dismissive and calling everyone you perceive as min maxer a gdstasher. I roll plenty of 0-100 builds legitimately. If anything I can’t comprehend people like you who pretend finishing a build to be like 90% or more of the way to BiS affixes and ascended bonuses is harder/more time consuming than it is.

You have also completely ignored the arguments made in this thread in favor of a boorish response. Are you going to respond to every view you don’t like with “pfft, gdstasher!” ??? Please be more mature.

This is exactly our point. You think I haven’t dropped amplicorum on plenty of my builds? Of course I have. I’m quite favorable toward the defensive pots.

The problem you are glazing over is that instead of just giving tanky builds a means to do more damage temporarily, this potion ends up pushing the peak builds even further, because their DPS reaches high enough to kill enemies before they can even use the more dangerous parts of their kit.

Also it’s not just 10%. Again, the potion is juiced and stacks multiplicatively with Sanginis. It’s hard to even converse with your points when you respond to me the way you do.

I’m friends with plenty of long term grinders who have far more characters than I level 100, who play purely SSF, and also share my view here.

To really simplify the point: imagine the difference between 10% TDM on a 100k DPS build vs. 1M DPS build.

It’s the same percentage for both, but a 10k DPS increase for one and a 100k DPS increase for the other. Same percentage value, but much bigger actual increase for the latter.

This is why we’re saying TDM on potions is actually boosting some of the strongest builds in the game even further as opposed to being a significant risky drawback to incorporate.

2 Likes

The issue is there’s too limited a number of potion modifiers to make that actually impactful.

You get a total of 4 potion slots. 1 can be armour, 1 can be hp barrier and then what? ADCtH? Max Speed?

There simply isn’t enough competition for the 4 available slots to make the opportunity cost feel relevant.

Which also plays directly into why the “Downsides” of these TDM potions can feel less impactful, as you have other potion slots that can mitigate them… Extra healing to cover Sanginis health drain, extra armour to cover Amplicorum’s increased damage…

This is one of the concerns in regards to how these modifiers affect builds unequally. A build that has plenty of resource sustain that doesn’t need to use potions for health/energy recovery can more readily use things like TDM, armour and barrier mods (And can get away with Revurrum to boost these modifiers). While a build with sustain issues that might actually use potions for being potions, is less able to use these buff modifiers and they compete with the bonus recovery mods.

I.e. Strong builds get stronger and weak builds get further away.

1 Like

The only point I can agree is that some of the alternative potion affixes need to be made more attractive / on the same level as the armor/TDM/leech ones.

Like the Move speed potion should also include Attack/Cast speed or just be a new affix altogether.
Or the one which gives you for 4sec 100% Freeze/Trap etc resist - this could get reduced to like 30-40% but made with 30sec duration - it would really be a god send for so many builds struggling to max stun/slow/freeze.

With latest patch both TDM are in a good spot, you have to make sacrifices and in many instances they are just not worth it vs the danger to get 1 shot and to ruin your roguelike run for example.

So buff/introduce new Potion affixes to allow for even more options - simple.

It’d be nice if you even attempted to acknowledge or engage with the concept that the TDM potions turn outlier strong builds into even bigger outliers.

To prove I’m trying to engage you in good faith, here are two counter points against my thread:

  • even for the outliers, the TDM pots only shave off time in SR and celestial bosses. Celestial bosses aren’t meaningful to repeatedly farm, and for pushing in SR eventually the detriment of the effect probably becomes not worth it compared to going full tank. So maybe we can just be like, eh who cares if it makes some of the fastest builds a bit faster? Maybe the issue is actually that altar should be able to be juiced harder so ascendant mode also has content where these potions are too big of a detriment even for the top builds.
  • maybe the issue isn’t the potions, but that the builds that can more easily mitigate using both need tuning down.

For #1 I think that’s a fair stance. But I do care. I think it messed up the range of performance in the game’s build diversity but beyond that it also has a very real effect here of skewing feedback. We will see a meta dominated by the use of these potions, and particularly by builds that naturally mitigate the downsides in ways other builds can’t.

For #2, yeah this is pretty valid and I suppose another way of going about balancing the game. But then you are doing build balance patches around the potions and that is just not what I’d like to see. I also think this is wrong because some class synergies, simply because of what their kits offer, are more capable of dealing with both TDM potions than others. So it skews class balance too.

Btw, if the build is using vials, even without Reverrum, it’s two 12%s, not 10%, totaling a 25.44% damage multiplier. To me that’s an insane amount of offensive power to have for 30s from potions, even with their drawbacks.

1 Like

When the meta is to make glass cannon builds that kill some piss-easy boss in less than X seconds without ever testing the build’s defenses, it’s no surprise that a potion feels OP if it sacrifices the very defenses that don’t matter according to the meta.

Or nerf the outliers rather than throwing more dev time into Just Buff Everything and all the corrections that will need to be done down the road.

What metrics would you use for testing defenses?

1 armor, 1 HP barrier and revurrum are already 3 slots. Max speed is amazing and feels like it has notable contribution to overall clear speed especially in campaign (which is kinda the main endgame content now with ascendant mode). Sanginis’s lifesteal is also quite large and can cover most if not all of your lifesteal needs on its own, freeing other gear/devo slots. Personally I don’t like the uptime, but I’ve also seen some players praise the massive DR from the DR pot.

Builds that have issues with sustain and actually have to use pots as pots can still use armor+barrier+adcth+revurrum and arguably get more because they’re getting full benefit from all 4 slots, while TDM pots have downsides built in. Stronger builds do get more raw DPS if they go full TDM, but if weaker builds get enough extra survivability to stand and hit stuff now instead of constantly kiting while potion heal is in cooldown they might not necessarily get further away in overall power.

There’s probably some cases where TDM stacking hits just the right breakpoint where you could kill something before it uses a special attack, but that needs a special circumstance where the build was already strong enough it almost doesn’t have to deal with the special attack in the first place, and the difference is just that last push. For regular mobs this doesn’t really matter as they’ll die fast enough anyways and isn’t usually a threat in the first place, so it’s mostly an issue with nemesis/celestials. But then again, if those builds can finish 80% of nemesis/celestials without interacting with their special attack, arguably the problem is with those builds rather than the TDM pots.

1 Like

There’s a really easy example of this: The mog celestial fight. Most mog timers are ~40 seconds or more (for really good builds) there are very few sub 30 second builds because of the DR that comes with his form change he casts about 8 seconds into the fight. There’s not really many (that I’ve seen) builds in the 15-30 second range, I literally only know of 1. You either kill him briefly after the form change because he was low or you have to wait for all the DR abilities to were off. The TDM potions are much like this; you end up hitting a timing breakpoint that is functionally worth a LOT more than you’d think. Another example would be trash mobs. Let’s pretend most trash mobs have 1 million hp. If you <swing sword, cast spell, vaguely motion at your pets > and 1 shot the mob then you move to the next one. 1 swing = 1 kill. If that swing took half a sec then you could kill 2 mobs a sec. Buuuut if you don’t have quite enough damage, say you hit for 900k instead of 1m, then it takes 2 swings. You don’t get to kill the mob in what, .6 seconds? You have to go through the entire animation again to kill the mob literally doubling your time to kill. This isn’t actually all that contrived of a scenario, it’s something very real I’ve experienced in crucible and SR. builds under certain DPS thresholds start taking exponentially more time because everything takes more time.

anywho; TDM potions are OP. I can still run both on most OP builds and builds that had trouble running both now can’t and the gap has just widened. Get rid of TDM potions.

Signed,
Celestial Hunter Heapheaus

5 Likes

Sigh. This is actually a really good point. Which brings me to:

I guess if we really wanted to be thorough, we’d need to collect all the OP builds that can get away with running both potions in juiced content and then determine:

  • Is there a pattern on why the collection of double TDM pot builds are OP? If so, nerf the root cause.
  • Is there only a small number of builds that can afford to run both in juiced content? Again, potentially means the builds are the issue, not the potions.
  • Is it easier to nerf these builds directly without overly adversely affecting other builds in the game? If not, it may be better to nerf the potions.

I think those would be the main points of consideration. I don’t think I have anything more to say on this topic in the meantime, I still feel the 30s duration on TDM should be closer to 8. But maybe 66.67% uptime wouldn’t change anything and just make them feel tedious instead of fun.