TDM on both Amplicorum and Sanginis is not healthy for the game

I rather see them removed and maybe replaced with something else.

Because the idea I feel is to help builds with weak damage potential but high survivability, into leveraging that survivability towards damage. In practice however, it feels like only the top builds with high damage potential are able to actually get away with paying the penalty because Life Leech is so strong and scales with damage.

I am curious about how things would be if the TDM modifiers also nerfed life leech, forcing builds to invest into regen and other sources of healing instead :thinking:. But it feels like simply removing them and buffing the weaker builds that were supposed to use the potions would be better, even if there is a price to be paid in less build diversity.

4 Likes

TDM is multiplicative afaik, that’s the first issue. So an additional source of TDM makes every other TDM source more powerful

I don’t really think so. There’s an archtype of builds that struggle more (fully reliant ADCTH squishy melee builds) but it’s worth it to drop flat / rr (some) / % damage to grab the extra TDM so in essence we’re still at a stage where if a build can’t run both TDM potions then it’s not been tinkered with enough IMO. This is naturally only feedback for softcore. I wouldn’t even pick up the sanginis recipe in HC.

At this point I don’t think so. It’s not just WPS builds that I’ve tried. I’ve tried caster builds, wps builds, melee, ranged etc. I don’t think it’s a single archtype. It’s either way too many singular OP sources that need to be toned or the potions should be changed. I really liked xervous’s idea of one potion (amplicornum probably) being an instant +5 onslaught stack potion or something. That would be REALLY interesting and take some level of thought around using.

This is exactly how it would feel. For many of my sub 15 second ravager builds (post 1.3.1.0) they take out 66-75% of ravager in 6 seconds with everything is ā€œupā€ and then smack him the rest of the time to finish him off. Multipliers on multipliers is stronk. This would just do the same thing potions already do and create a divide between builds that can vs can’t abuse.

edit:

On almost every single build I have this wouldn’t effect the build in any major way. Passive health regen isn’t very strong right now on most builds. There’s a few arcanist builds that have some insane regen but outside of those almost everything is running ADCTH. I think basically every sub 15 second ravager build I have right now can fully heal from 1 hp to full off a single hit. I’m not actually sure how much ā€œoverhealā€ they’re doing either, so nerfing life leech might not actually help.

oorrrrrr you end up with the exact same situation of: Deep divide between builds that can vs can’t run the potions.

2 Likes

I completely forgot that this forum is ā€œgovernedā€ and ā€œranā€ by the self proclaimed ā€œeliteā€ whose opinion and view point if the only one that is ā€œcorrectā€ and the rest are dismissed as ā€œrudeā€, ā€œboringā€ and just not worth the time to be read.

Love also being called immature by a random person on the internet, makes me smile considering where I am in life and probably where are you if you spend so much time and energy insulting and being passive aggressive to people who just share their opinion on a video game.

tdlr: Make both TDM potions mutually exclusive - like you run one or the other - easy fix!
/peace

Buddy, your very first post out the gate was dismissive and condescending, and you know it. Nobody has said you’re wrong for liking the potions as they are. My frustration with you is you don’t even engage with the ideas or points being presented. Nobody has an issue with you being a contrarian. It is you who seemed immediately hostile in your first response. Ofc we fundamentally disagree on some things, but I have zero problem with that.

You group people together who use GDstash to test builds faster as ā€œelitistsā€ that you’re free to invalidate, then act like others started it for giving you pushback on how you chose to respond, and selectively ignore points being made. IDK man, are you rage baiting or something? I’m telling you the truth, most of the long term Gdstashers also do builds 1-100 from time to time too. I have a level 53 sorcerer in HC rn I’m working on. After thousands of hours it’s nice to mix things up. The majority of them are not out of touch with building characters normally, heck some of them make spreadsheets about it lol.

I have no idea how to make peace with you, but I’d like to. Please correct me if I’m wrong, but you seem almost hellbent alienating a group of people because you disapprove of their use of GDStash. I just don’t see anything to indicate you’re responding to people you perceive as gdstasher in good faith.

For what it’s worth, I think making them mutually exclusive would at least be an improvement. It’d skew high end performance less.

1 Like

Agreed, TDM was too delicious. And hard to balance, there would always be builds that can get away with using both.

IMO there’s four potion mods that are altering potion use in an undesirable way (design-wise, at least). The TDM ones are just the biggest outlier among those because they are the only offensive ones. But Terrobullum and Draculus are in the same boat: permanent uptime buff that has nothing to do with you drinking your potion when needed. These are just blanket inflating player stats. And I say that as someone who has multiple builds that live or die by having Terrobullum armor. My Thane who was slapping Ravager of Souls no problem before in under a minute can now after the Terrobullum nerf get one-shot by the headbutt attack post-enrage if I’m already sundered (which with Ravager of Souls is all the time). My retal Zealot is basically dead without Draculus, as it makes up 12 out of its 17 % lifesteal. Retal builds are just screwed when it comes to access to lifesteal.

I think the potion mods that are time limited are great, even though not all are created equal. Potentis vs Expulsimum is not even a comparison, but at least Expulsimum still doesn’t prevent you from getting blown up permanently, it helps bridge gaps or stabilise you when you dip low but doesn’t solve your DR problem for you. Savillis + Flask is now a neat circuit breaker, Geliodis does exactly what you’d want your potion to do, i.e. save you in a pinch, etc.

I’m sure Amplicorum and Sanginis were originally intended for builds that end up overly tanky by nature but short on damage and that idea I could get behind, but it’s just impossible to isolate the use case to just those situations. I feel like the nerf did reinforce that idea, with you needing to have a truly substantial amount of tankiness to make up for Amplicorum now, since the damage taken scales more than the damage going out, and I feel like Sanginis is possibly there already. Like yeah, if I’m just DPSing down Ravager the bleed doesn’t matter. But if I use it in CR I can just bleed out in between wave spawns and then I’m starting the next one with no health. When I need to circlekite to split up wave 200, I can’t, any instance of damage will kill me during it. If regen builds are still a thing (haven’t seen any) I’m sure they’re happy Sanginis exists, but turns out lifesteal builds benefit more from it anyway as their sustain scales with the TDM, while a regen build’s doesn’t. So it just ends up reinforcing an already powerful playstyle, and skews some numbers to not really represent real use situations. Superboss times go down cause that’s a controllable, 100% DPS uptime situation, while real use cases get worse for most builds and the outliers still end up being powerful by being able to slot in both.

TLDR: as much as some of my chars are reliant on Terrobullum and Draculus, I think the potion mods are at their best when following the pattern of Geliodis, Savillis or Menhirus. They help in a pinch. They don’t fix the build. As long as what the potions provide is achievable through reasonable means (pls give Retal builds actual lifesteal access), I think it’d be better if these perma-uptime pots went away. Though we could use some extra options to replace them, without these four, the useful potion mod pool is left a bit thin.

1 Like

Can I suggest for all monsters to deal more damage so that in ultimate/ascendant you will need to use the healing potions as your BiS? Give them a lower cd or other healing perks as choices. Keep the tdm potions for the casuals who play on normal or elite.

I think the issue with that is the way the game is designed.

ADCtH can already heal people for their full health bar per hit. Making things do more damage won’t make such a build need to use potions.

This is also the reason why circuit breakers like Menhir’s Will are not well liked. The design of the game is not that you’re slowly being chipped away at. It’s very bursty. You get chunked for massive damage, then you heal up massive HP.

Which is also why Health Regen (And more recently % Health Recovery) has never been favourable. As you need so much investment to get absurd values to compete with the heavy burst damage (And then its recovery is much slower than ADCtH as it only does a few thousand per second not ā€œ20k in an instantā€)

More damage just makes things more bursty and further pushes reliance on ADCtH in order to keep up. Rather than making potions more lucrative (Outside maybe Savillis as a circuit breaker… Which again, has the same problem of Menhir’s Will whereby you just get bursted to 0 health before it can activate)

Realistically, it’s impossible to make healing potions actually required in the current game. You’d have to completely redesign how ADCtH functions (Which I’m not entirely sure is even possible in this engine) so that it doesn’t just provide such extreme recovery (As well as ensure that other sources of sustain like Regen and heal procs don’t easily cover all your needs)

2 Likes

Both TDM pots should go. They add more bad than good, simple as that.

The only potion mods design I really like rn are HP over time instead of burst and DR AoE nuke. Leech, max movspeed and armor ones seem ok overall as padding the crucial stat gaps you have, just not a fan of pots being permabuffs you need to upkeep.

We need more situational utility from the mods, not making the pots into another two permabuff buttons. We also need chance on attack to extend duration for all pots, similar to PB or BoD.

8 Likes

How about removing TDM and instead giving it a slightly different defensive status? For example, increasing evasion rate while increasing damage taken, greatly increasing DA while taking slip damage, or decreasing movement speed while increasing healing ability.

As someone who generally tries to bring suggestions for design rather than point out what is currently ā€œwrongā€, here are a few options for potions that could be implemented.

I have not been using the 2 TDM potions so far, and not only because I have not found them yet :sweat_smile: but because I don’t want to be refreshing yet another buff all the time. I can understand their value, and the reason they are using a TDM to make them universal.

Bearing in mind that in my opinion, potions should be inherently defensive and focused on healing and such.

First of all, I think potions should have a much longer duration. A full 2 minutes duration should not be a problem for Max movement speed for example. I would put an even longer duration on it, make it 5 minutes… It’s not like it changes much.

It’s curious that there isn’t one that increases max resists. Maybe this one could be short duration, but it’s a good panic button option, and would give value to resist overcaps.

There is no health Regen potions. Not is there a ā€œrestored %health per secondā€ one, which seems like they would be natural fits.

One that gives Dodge and evade chance would be easy to balance and straightforward for players to measure its value.

A low value % damage absorb would also be super attractive, especially for masteries that already have access to some, like Arcanist, Shaman and Occultist.

I know this is really a tangent on the current discussion, but if the devs are reading this, let there be some suggested alternatives in the same place to pick up the slack.

I like that potions are customizable now, so they can fill in the holes in your character’s flaws. But with more options, the chances are that fewer people will go straight for the same 2-3 choices all the time.

5 Likes

In my opinion that would be a required potion modifier even more so than some of the others as +% Max All Resists is a huge defensive buff and is rightly limited in the slots and places you can get it.

Having it on Inquisitor’s Seal during the last PT was broken when combined with other +% Max Resists sources… :eyes:

All the other options would be certainly nice to have as additions to the modifier system! :sunglasses:

1 Like

I get it, it can’t be something like +5% or it would create builds that are totally immune. It also can’t last like 30 seconds…

But +5% for 5 seconds… or +3% for 10-15 seconds is doable.

For most builds this is a neat bonus, nothing more. But for some builds that already have hinger than normal max resist values, this would become a no-brainer, and the equivalent of activating mirror.

That difference leads to more diversity.

The best example of that currently in the game are the one that gives armor and block chance, which is only useful for builds that rely on blocking, and the one that adds ADCtH … which is great, but only useful for builds that rely on life leech to begin with.

Some builds rely on health regen, but they have no potion mod that help with that. If there was one, it would probably be useless to most builds… but very much worth it for health regen-focused builds :slight_smile:

1 Like

Id say that chance to extend duration will just certainly push them into being permabuffs - not sure if that’s the right direction to go for the game, but on the other hand now it’s bad QoL if thats what the devs are aiming for.

The movement speed one feels for me one that’s in the perfect spot - if you don’t refresh in time, no harm done, it’s just a nice bonus. For the other pots the case is less easy

Max resist potion would be way too OP, even if only for a short duration, this effectively promotes more button smashing and personally I dont find that very enjoyable. The risk with health/sec is that you can combine it with one of the TDM pots (forgot the name, not amplicorum, still havent gotten it either :sweat_smile:) and use that as net buff which will make it mandatory in 90% of the cases (edit: what tdm pots are now doing already actually)

Lets also keep in mind Potions were designed to act as a power creep/ alt power progression outside of the leveling curve.
I recall Zantai being clear on that when there was a discussion about why we dont get more char levels in FoA.
It is a clever approach instead of more levels to add stuff like Ascendancy mods to items and Potions.
What I am saying - Potions were designed as those semi perma/perma buffs which have a significant effect on your build.
They should stay and only get added more affixes etc - i really like the feature.

TDM should be mutually exclussive, also add bigger % penalty for higher % bonus - like increase the dmg intake to 20% if you are going for that 12% TDM

you can get powercreep with potion buffs
it doesn’t mean that powercreep has to be a game negative because it’s too huge or has too wide disparity.

I keep saying when you have even pro powercreep players react with ā€œthis is too muchā€, it should a nudge it’s not a positive game benefit amount of boost :sweat_smile:

If anywhere, the +max resists could be on the circruit breaker potion. Might make it more desirable as right now even in hardcore I’d much prefer other mods.

1 Like

Yep delete both potions :smiley:

I agree with the notion TDM potions should be deleted.

I don’t like the idea of potions being two another buffs which should be refreshed every 30 seconds.

Modifiers like Savilis, Alterom, Revurrum, Sansochromatis are great as they give variety in how you use your potions which were and should be used for mana/hp restoration, not for permanent buffs.

That’s why i don’t like idea of Draculus, Terrobullum and Menhirus: they are like compulsory now for low amor, auto-attacking builds, no variety here - unless your build runs both TDM modifiers which is crazy.

2 Likes