You know, guys, I had a weird moment of clarity when I realized on some level how annoying we are.
The TDM potions, when added with love, were probably just a fun thing they thought players would enjoy with a higher-risk drawback, and for most people, that’s probably all they are. After all, technically everything in here is just for fun. It’s probably a bit frustrating for developers when they just want to add a cool thing and we immediately translate it into how it affects balance in a (pretty much) non-competitive game. I’m not saying the arguments presented here are invalid, but there’s definitely a more chill perspective that’s equally as valid.
For the problem I described of them skewing build performance… we could just let it go. There’s a pretty simple solution in regard to boss times and SR times; we just ask builders to include times without the TDM potions. If we, as a community, reject the way they skew build performance, then they won’t. I’m not pendulum swinging here, for less skilled players they probably are too much risk together to pilot with.
I still don’t love that much offensive power baked into a potion for 30s, but eh, it’s a game, and removing them would also remove the fun they provide for builds that do struggle to use one or both.
I’m not saying builds can’t showcase how they do with them; vanity metrics are fun too! I just think they should show how they do without them first.
To be fair, the game is 10 years old and they’ve been doing a lot of balance adjustments over that time.
They really ought to have known that global TDM would cause these issues with regards to players min-maxing with them. Given they’ve been chasing down min-maxers with balance changes this whole time.
The intent might have been a way for high defence and low damage builds to switch into being more evenly split. But they had to have known that people would be pushing them on glass builds and finding work arounds to manage them.
As far as “Fun” goes… They’re pretty boring. Global TDM isn’t very interesting besides “Look at the big number” and if the intent was for these to be used on low damage builds that have the excess tankiness to offset the downsides, then you wouldn’t even get “Big number”
Meanwhile, this can also be seen as a bandaid fix to address such builds in lieu of actually adjusting them so they have the desired performance.
Which is one of the major points about outside of build modifiers, they’re non-specific. Which causes discrepancies like this. If you create a modifier to help a particular build (Be it something offensive like TDM or defensive like the Armour potion), but it can be used on other builds that don’t need it to be competitive then they can just get more stronger.
Meaning, even though the one particular build was intended to benefit from it, all it does is make that build fall further behind because the good builds also benefit from it and tend to compound with the natural strength of the good build.
You could probably get away with things if they had limitations or requirements. For example, if TDM potions were for high defence builds, then have the damage bonus be a conversion from some defence stats. Meaning you HAVE to have high defence to get the damage, not just some way to overcome some detrimental effect (Though you’d likely still run into the issue where stacked builds that have both obscene damage and high defensive stats get to have their cake and eat it…)
The negative effects are NOT fun. And the global TDM is so ridiculous that it’s not fun either. As someone said earlier, the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. No need to defend a bad mechanic, the devs can handle constructive criticism just fine.
Anyway, delete TDM potions please. Here’s another perspective: they invalidate the TDM effects that skill modifiers can provide. What’s the point in using MIs with TDM anymore? Or using a specific type of weapon to get TDM on a skill (savagery, bone harvest)? Just use a potion, who cares about balance.
15 Naddo kills to get it
Funnily enough Avinnia with Ventorus was actually the worst luck, taking almost 30 kills
I got 4 explosim in the same time(3 spares)
I still haven’t got it and 1 of the ones that Beronath drops. Been farming for 4 days, at least 50 kills on naddo. I’ve moved onto a new character for now. I’ve had like 5 Amplicorum and Potentis drop but no Savilis
Yeah I am not doing that. Let’s not shift responsibility for certain game design decisions from devs onto builders.
As I said before, me (and other top20 builders) are always building with Amplicorum (not just Amplicorum but Amplicorum with 50% more potency from Rank 5 Vial) in mind. So the negative effects of it are also baked into build design - I am not making glassier builds because of Amplicorum. As much as I dislike those new potions design as a builder and min-maxer I will always be trying to find the most optimal ways to make a build with the tools that Crate gave us. And reality (for me at least) is that you either try to make it tanky with Amplicorum or you don’t bother because difference between using it and not using it is just too big.
Depends on the build, there is no particular set of stats or DA/armor/whatever breakpoints that will negate the effects of incoming tdm. I just make it so it feels tanky enough to my liking in all the endgame challenges that I test it in. You can see how the melees builds that I make look on my YT. All have a lot of hp/DA/armor/sustain, etc., but most importantly all can dispatch of the dangerous foes fast.
Ooof… So Crate decide to experiment with duration and tries to make poisons more tactical. Like we should push poison buttons in most dangerous moments and nothing else. Like we already didn’t have enough buttons here is more. That’s not gonna work for good imo.
*i fully expect people to complaint about this so much it gets eventually reverted
but i think it’s a step in the right direction instead of perma buffs for some of those
Personally, I just see this as making me not want to interact with any of the modifiers listed there. I already removed TDM ones when the cost became too high for my builds. Now, even armor and move speed ones will have to go.
I am not for or against the change since I can’t predict how this will shape the overall balance of the modifiers but I am against having to micro manage potions though an argument can be made that it is how they are supposed to be used - only when needed. But I will content myself with just the heal and energy ones or something instead.
I think this is going to be what the potions in the playtest are gonna be used for. Now they’re basically ghoul buttons. Terrobullum + Draculus is essentially ghoul. And then you get something like menhirus + ventorus or the cc res one on the other potion. Or new Sanginis + Sansochromatis.
Amplicorum is gonna be non-existent in the playtest outside of ravager speedkills (so you’ll still see Heaph do it)
Share the same sentiment - the last thing we need is more button pushing every 6 seconds…
I think I will just not engage with this mechanic (and i dropped TDM potions as a whole post 1.3.1) - the quality of life impact is going to be dramatic and I already stopped playing combos which have horrible short duration debuffs like Occultist having to cast CoF every 5 seconds (honestly this should be an aura effect).
At the least there should be valid way to prolong the duration of the potion effects.
Maybe add a mini skill tree for Potions should be fun.
But isnt it the way to promote that spam? If you have short but powerful effect, you think about when to press it. If you have about 100% uptime effect you just whip AHK and ask nearby AI chat to write a macro to autopress it. And at that stage they are effectively permanent auras/buffs (see Blood of Dread etc) so the next logical step is to make them like that.
I don’t think that’s how this will play out. People will use the CD-reduction flasks and have >50% uptime if they just spam it. It won’t make sense to save it.
Spamming is so much more annoying now tho. I imagine nearly everyone will hate it. And maybe that’s the solution. Make the mechanic so annoying that everyone interacts with it the "intended’ way