But then those flask effects would be mostly useless,… which is fine IMO. Either you are lazy and accept sub-par performance or you are actively pressing your buttons and get rewarded with high effective uptime. IMO existence of both options while non-lazy option is properly rewarded is fine.
I get the impression that this is intended to be a kind of panic button, but 4 to 6 seconds seems far too short. In the first place, a temporary panic button is often useless against truly dangerous enemies in GD. Crowd control doesn’t work, you’re immediately caught if you run, and in most cases, you’ll die instantly. Savilis might be essential.
Why would they be mostly useless? If you have 4 sec buffs on a 7 sec CD there’s no point saving them. Perhaps I am misunderstanding your point.
Yep I totally agree, this just seems like a very shortsighted change imo.
I think if you want people to press the pots more “stratetigically” or whatever, a better solution would be to add a new pot basetype for “-50% duration, 100% effect” (or whatever numbers make sense) and nerf the base effect values if those are too problematic.
Making the durations 4-6sec just sounds like way too much piano, and it might make some pots a lot worse overall. For example, I think block for example gets pretty much enabled by the block pot giving you block chance (though the patch notes read as it giving damage blocked? Maybe I missed a change here) and having that be 4sec just sounds pointless to me. Of course the main purpose of that pot is the %armour, which is pretty busted, but imo those should be separate pot modifiers in the 1st place.
Nerfing TDM pots (again) is good though. Maybe just remove those next patch? ![]()
Yeah I think the only pots that properly fit this role are the absorb pot (or well, if the absorb was not based on your current hp…) and the “circuit breaker” pot, that triggers at 40% hp or whatever, but even that is automated (and kinda too weak to use imo).
I feel like this sort of pot playstyle doesn’t really work that well unless we have a dedicated pot basetype for it.
Ok so what was the ask here? I thought the general concensus was that potions being permabuffs doesn’t really fit their theme and completely transformed how they are used, turning from “on demand” to “another Word of Renewal I need to upkeep”. So, Zantai turns them into temporary buffs so that they are used as intended: shore up your survivability for a brief moment on demand. Immediate reaction: “it’s gonna be so much button mashing now, the duration is too short so it will be hard to upkeep permanently”. Le sigh. One suggestion that might satisfy both camps: what if Savillis became its own potion type?
My take: Amplicorum is still not really fixed. The damage taken is even more punishing so now only the builds that are already super stacked will be able to afford it (rich get richer) and the duration being 6 s means you can mostly have it full time with a Tincture pot. Means that using it with Vial is basically gonna go out the window, which I suppose is the goal, but for the 7 s potters, the TDM problem still remains. And if you can burst down a boss in 18 seconds then you could even take it with a Flask.
Draculus: I’m not sure it will find much of a home now. With a 4 s duration it will serve the purpose of burst healing that one would want from a heal pot, but because builds can no longer rely on it, they will need to have good lifesteal one way or another to bridge the gap. And if they already have good lifesteal, will they really want to dedicate a slot to Draculus at that point? Wouldn’t they rather take Terrobullum or Sanginis to tank up, rather than overstack their already sufficient leech? This change and Terrobullum I dread the most cause I noticed already with the nerfed Terrobullum some boss fights got shakier on some of my builds (e.g. Ravager of Souls unless you diligently dodge every Wraith sunder), so now I wonder how many will be wrecked completely by this. And as for Draculus, I agree that a potion probably shouldn’t be solving a thing that normally a build would need to dedicate some effort into fixing. But on the other hand, in some instances I really don’t see great ways to fix the lifesteal problem in the first place. Put together a retaliation build these days with the ideal gear and devo map and look at your lifesteal. Those items and constellations have nothing to offer for sustain. Draculus was a bandaid, yes, but if that bandaid is going away, now we just have an open wound.
Ventorus: I’m not sure how much this was used in actual endgame, but I think I’d prefer this one to have the Phillom treatment and just be a really long uptime little buff. It’s so convenient for speed levelling and I don’t think having permanent extra MS really breaks anything at endgame. Map traversal on new chars is going to be so slow without this.
The lower duration was precisely made to stop the spamming of potions. Now you use them in specific situations, instead of constantly having to refresh them. So it’s less buttons to push.
I can’t say for sure until I try it, but personally, I think I’ll have fewer opportunities to use vials. I’ll probably end up creating macros for tinctures or flasks.
Thought about the new potion changes a little more and I do see one big problem on the horizon: Tincture. The big thing players have to combat in the game is getting one-shot. Any source of extra tankiness is extremely welcome. The idea of limiting the effect of these defense-bolstering potions to 4 seconds does make it so we can’t upkeep them permanently and need to be defensive enough in the downtimes, but Tincture throws that out of the window. Set up one potion with Tincture and Terrobullum for +50%!! armor, set the other potion with Tincture and Sanginis for +30% health. Now you just rotate between them. One or the other massive defensive buff is always on. With 12 s potions the design of the timed buffs works as intended but Tincture screws it up.
Yep. This is where all the “too much button mashing” complaints come from. You’re not using potions when you need it. You come up with a strategy to always have two buffs active and now it’s basically the same as before but you just remove the tdm problem.
Hm, so what if, like Savilis, these effects had a cooldown? The frequency of the potion use would get separated from the potion type they’re on. Though then there would be the problem of finding a way to make the 7 s and 12 s potions line up in a way where the potion effect cooldown can be active within a reasonable rotation for both.
Then again, I feel like it’s only really Terrobullum and the new Sanginis that give you this option. The absorb shield doesn’t last long enough to overlap, Expulsimum DR is only really relevant for some builds that don’t already have a better DR source. Maybe the easier solution is to do something else with Sanginis and then you don’t need to overhaul Tincture and the button mashing kinda goes away, cause there’s only really one defensive buff you would even try to upkeep.
How about exchanging Ventorus’ Evasion with Sanginis’ 30% Health? 20% Evasion might be a bit too strong for NB. You could always get 40% Evasion. If there’s a drawback of constantly decreasing HP in exchange for increased Evasion, it might be somewhat balanced.
This change is a step in the right direction.
I think the big hang up right now, is that too many of the potion effects are proactive rather than reactive.
A proactive buff like evasion, the absorb, armour etc. You want to have up BEFORE you take damage, which in the case of very bursty damage output this game utilises, leads into wanting to have it perma-active.
While the short duration effects will always feel better when you use them in response to something happening. Like the baseline potion effect you use it when you’re low health/energy to get instant recovery, you might use the CC resistance effect after being hit by CC etc.
In a reactive scenario, the duration is irrelevant to your usage. You press it for the impact right away. But for the proactive scenario you want to be able to predict its need, which often just means “Obtain 100% uptime because the game isn’t FFXIV and made entirely of scripted encounters”
Of course, such a thing highlights the inherent problem with the entire system within the game as it currently exists. That being, there’s so incredibly few effects that are worthwhile as reactives given the bursty nature of the game.
Like, in another game where TTK is slower, having a big boost of armour, evasion or leech can be helpful reactively. You get blasted and this keeps you alive while you recover health over a few seconds.
But in GD? Such things don’t have the same impact because if you get burst down… You just insta-leech back up to full.
I mean that a defense with a 50% automated uptime is not what will really work when you want. Yes it will cover some damage, but I (and hc players I talked about this) would not even consider that a defense.
This one you actually want to use proactively. It won’t free you from a CC effect you’re already under, it negates one you’re about to take.
Imo most of the potions aren’t something you want to be using in specific situations so this just seems like a pointless change to me. Just gives me PoE1 potion vibes honestly.
Making the TDM pots lower duration is definitely the right way to go (aside from just removing them from the game
) but I don’t think the armour pots etc. being lower duration really makes sense. Something like a “reverse” absorb potion that’s based on max or missing hp would be a better fit for this sort of playstyle

That would make sense in a different type of dynamic - GD is, thankfully, fast paced and “bursty”.
Those are core traits and considerable reason why many players pick it up.
I dont think having 4-6-12 sec duration reactive potions would work in such a context - things happen just way too fast and quickly for the player to actually react.
And that reaction honestly wont make a big difference.
Lowering duration for TDM or just make the dmg penalty like 20% at a base instead - would have been enough.
Also the effects on most potions arent reactive in nature thus it is a counterproductive measure without any benefit.
Personally I am not going to mash a button every 4-6-12sec on top monitoring all the gazzilion debuffs on myself and trying to avoid the 164234 visual and ground effects.
Will withhold final judgement after i play it but I just cant see it fitting this game style.
50% uptime is better than anything less than 50%, no? There’s no point in saving the CD because it will be back up 3 seconds after the effect expires. I play a lot of hardcore too and imo cooldowns are there to be used - no point hoarding them for the next character.
How is this any different than Ascension and other similar temporary buffs? You save those for specific situations.
Or are you also always spamming Ascension when the cd is off?